Banner
    The Plot Of The Week - The Source Of Higgs Bosons
    By Tommaso Dorigo | May 29th 2014 09:58 AM | 2 comments | Print | E-mail | Track Comments
    About Tommaso

    I am an experimental particle physicist working with the CMS experiment at CERN. In my spare time I play chess, abuse the piano, and aim my dobson...

    View Tommaso's Profile
    One of the nice details lost in the big picture of the Higgs boson discovery of 2012 is that a significant part of the signal put in evidence by ATLAS and CMS is produced by a very special kind of interactions between the protons accelerated by the LHC. These are "vector boson fusion" processes, whereby it is not the protons or its constituents that come in direct contact, but rather, each proton emits a W boson, and it is the latter pair which fuse together, give rise to a Higgs particle.

    You realize that such is a quite extraordinary concept. You should picture two cars launched one against the other at high speed, when the drivers just a moment before the impact shoot a bullet at each other. As a result of the recoils, the two cars deviate from their straight path and miss each other, while it is the bullets that collide with one another.

    W bosons are seldom fired by energetic protons, as the interaction responsible of their emission by a matter particle (be it a quark or a lepton -in this case a quark, which is a proton constituent) is much weaker than the strong interaction which usually takes place when two protons collide. Hence you can understand that we are talking of a really rare occurrence: this makes sense, as the Higgs discovery was really a tough experimental challenge.

    If rather than looking for Higgs production by vector-boson scattering we try to isolate W boson pairs that, although emitted by the same mechanism, "missed" each other -as if we looked for pairs of bullets emitted by the two colliding - we will have trouble separating such events from ones where the two W bosons were emitted by a more normal quark-antiquark interaction when the protons collided: such mixed "strong and weak" interactions are much more frequent and it becomes very hard to identify the strange vector boson scatterings we are after. However, we can look for pairs of W boson of the same electric charge: in this case, strong interactions are suppressed, and the signal can be evidenced more readily.

    That is precisely what ATLAS just did, as reported in a paper sent to the Arxiv a week ago. They looked for the signal of two W bosons, each producing a electron-neutrino or muon-neutrino pair, with the two charged leptons being of the same charge. The event topology is further enriched in the signal component by selecting events that also possess two energetic jets, as the W boson emissions produce a recoil of the quarks that fired them. These quarks are thus expelled from the parent proton and produce hadronic jets. By selecting pairs of jets that have a large invariant mass the vector boson scattering signal is amplified.

    At the end of the selection chain, ATLAS produces a "money plot" where a kinematical characteristic of the event candidates (a function of the angle between the two jets) is compared between data (black points with error bars) and the sum of all expected standard model processes (stacked coloured histograms), which of course includes the searched signal (in light blue). As you can see, the "signal region" at high values of the kinematical variable shown in the graph would contain an excess of data with respect to backgrounds, if one were to assume that no vector-boson scattering contribution were present.



    The excess of signal-like events allows ATLAS to estimate the cross section of this fancy process, which is found in good agreement with predictions (as the graph itself does show). The cross section of electroweak production of same-sign W pairs, multiplied by acceptance and selection factors, is found to be 1.3+-0.4+-0.2 femtobarns.

    What is next ? It would be really nice to see pairs of Z bosons produced by the same mechanism, but the lack of a charge makes the separation of that process from "ordinary" production of Z bosons really hard at present. Rather, it will be interesting to revisit the studied process with more statistics and higher center-of-mass energy next year, as the variable shown in the graph above, which is a characteristic "tag" of the vector boson scattering, is not very well studied and would benefit from a higher statistical power.


    Comments

    Thanks - I had not seen this detail of how some of the detected Higgs were produced before. The car-and-bullet analogy is a good one!

    dorigo
    Thank you Kent. Yes, the car and bullet analogy works, sort of - but I am wondering if there is a better way to convey the rarity of this kind of interaction and the peculiar kinematics it gives rise... One thing that analogy misses is that the two rifles must be shot in the opposite direction as they fire the bullets, and exit the cars. They are the two hadronic jets...

    Cheers,
    T.