Banner
    Lady Liberty’s Green Veneer: As Complex As Freedom
    By Enrico Uva | July 11th 2011 06:27 AM | 6 comments | Print | E-mail | Track Comments
    About Enrico

    I majored in chemistry, worked briefly in the food industry and at Fisheries and Oceans. I then obtained a degree in education. Since then I have...

    View Enrico's Profile
    Patina is a beautiful, green mixture of products derived from copper at the mercy of oxidation, various forms of pollution and thermodynamics. It not only coats the Statue of Liberty but is found on bronze statues, copper roofs and old copper dishes, hence the name patina, Latin for dish.

    If you take powdered copper and heat it in a crucible, the combination of increased surface area and higher average kinetic energy augment the likelihood of successful encounters between copper and oxygen. What forms is CuO, named copper(II) oxide, once known as cupric oxide. Under natural and milder conditions, Cu2O forms. Although some sheltered bits persist as such, for most atoms it is not copper's ultimate fate. In Cu2O, copper's oxidation state is only +1. When further oxidation occurs thanks to moisture and oxygen, each Cu+  loses another electron to become Cu2+. The ions eventually bind to hydroxide(OH-) and to sulfate(SO42-), a sulfur dioxide (SO2) derivative. Hydroxide ion is a product of oxidation which also makes its appearance in the corrosion of steel. Sulfur dioxide, is an emission of volcanoes, smelters and coal power plants. The compound made is posnjakite, Cu4(SO4)(OH)6 · 2H2O , but it eventually turns into the same compound found in a greenish mineral named brochantite.

    Brochantite, Cu4(OH)6SO4, more accurately represented as CuSO4.3Cu(OH)2, is usually patina's main compound, but from naked eye observations alone, it's obvious that patina cannot be only brochantite. For one thing, unlike Lady Liberty's veneer, the mineral is either translucent or transparent, and the latter would not cling to her.

    Prior to research done during the years of the Great Depression, it was believed that a different mineral , basic copper carbonate--- malachite (CaCO3.Cu(OH)2) was patina's major constituent. The chemists' investigation revealed that regardless of the patina's source, it was only a minor component which nevertheless contributed to patina's opaque nature. Interestingly, if the patina's origin was rural, it would makeup a bit less than 3% of the whole; if from London, the percent of the carbonate mineral would be as high as 24. The higher concentrations of carbon dioxide in the urban setting were responsible for this as copper ions soaked up CO2, combining with ionic products of the gas. If it were not for the prohibitively expensive cost of copper roofs, replacing typical bituminous (so-called asphalt) roof shingles with copper ones would be an attractive green alternative, in more ways than one.

    Patina on outdoor plumbing in MontrealCopper's proximity to the sea and its source of chloride will influence the percentage of a third green mineral constituent, atacamite (CuCl2.3Cu(OH)2). During the Statue of Liberty's restoration 25 years ago, Bell Research labs applied some more sophisticated techniques than were available during the depression years to analyze patina. They found that in some samples, atacamite was even more prevalent than brochantite. (I wonder if patina from cold inland cities exposed to lots of winter street salt also show elevated levels of atacamite.) When they heated patinas, mass spectrographical analysis of the resulting gases not only confirmed the presence of carbonates from the decomposition of malachite but also oxalates, another indication of patina's complexity.

    But what makes the minerals cling to the copper underneath the patina? To investigate this, the Bell researchers used acetone, the main constituent of nail polish remover. This solvent will not dissolve patina's minerals but will extract various hydrocarbons which were revealed by mass spec to be monocarboxylic acids, alkanes, and polynuclear aromatic compounds. If old patina is removed and placed on a fresh sheet of copper, within a week organic pollutants will bind it to the unoxidized metal. According to another Bell study, old patina's "organic glue" is strong enough to make it resistant to most acidic precipitation, with the possible exception of acidic fog. Do not, however, imagine that the patina is completely insoluble. A copper roof's patina loses between 1.0 and 1.5 g/m2 of copper per year according to a 2002 Swedish study.

    The strength of the bond between patina and metal is up to point proportional to the time the patina is exposed to the atmosphere. There are many recipes that can be used to quickly form patina, but the lab versions tend to flake off. Powder X ray diffraction techniques also reveal that synthetic patinas have smaller crystals since they formed more quickly. These characteristics help investigators identify forged artifacts which are given a fake coating to make them look old. The uninitiated often do not realize that even in a non living colored mixture, there is far more than meets the eye.

    References

    R.L. Opilaa AT&T Bell Laboratories. Copper patinas: an investigation by Auger electron spectroscopy Corrosion Science.
    Volume 27, Issue 7, 1987, Pages 685-694

    K Nassaua, A.E Millera and T.E Graedela AT&T Bell Laboratories. The reaction of simulated rain with copper, copper patina, and some copper compounds. Corrosion Science
    Volume 27, Issue 7, 1987, Pages 703-719

    Amy J. Mullera and Carolyn McCrory-Joy AT&T Bell Laboratories. Chromatographic Analysis of copper patinas formed in the atmosphere. Corrosion Science
    Volume 27, Issue 7, 1987, Pages 695-701

    K. Nassaua, P.K. Gallaghera, A.E. Millera and T.E. Graedela
    The characterization of patina components by X-ray diffraction and evolved gas analysis. Corrosion Science. Volume 27, Issue 7, 1987, Pages 669-684

    B. De Filippo et al. Characterization of Bronze Corrosion Products on Exposition to Sulphur Dioxide. Advanced Materials Research (Volume 138) 2010

    1929 - Vernon and Whitby. “The Open-Air Corrosion of Copper. A Chemical Study of the Surface Patina”. J. Inst. Metals, 24, no. 2, 1929, pp. 181-95.

    Ivars Peterson "Lessons learned from a lady; the recent Statue of Liberty restoration provided some unique research opportunities". Science News.
    http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1200/is_v130/ai_4610599/

    Paul Craddock. Scientific investigation of copies, fakes and forgeries. Butterworth-Heinemann. 2009

    C. Karlén, I. Odnevall Wallinder D. Heijerickand C. Leygraf. Runoff rates, chemical speciation and bioavailability of copper released from naturally patinated copper. Environmental Pollution Volume 120, Issue 3, December 2002, Pages 691-700

    Comments

    rholley
    Huckleberry was filled with admiration of Tom's facility in writing, and the sublimity of his language. He at once took a pin from his lapel and was going to prick his flesh, but Tom said:

    "Hold on! Don't do that. A pin's brass. It might have verdigrease on it."

    "What's verdigrease?"

    "It's p'ison. That's what it is. You just swaller some of it once – you'll see."

    So Tom unwound the thread from one of his needles, and each boy pricked the ball of his thumb and squeezed out a drop of blood.
    Robert H. Olley / Quondam Physics Department / University of Reading / England
    rholley
    Here is the copper roof on the old Physics Department (still called the J.J.Thomson Building), where I worked up to last year.  Certainly keeps down the maintenance costs!


    Robert H. Olley / Quondam Physics Department / University of Reading / England
    UvaE
    At McGill, here In Montreal, the physics building is named after Rutherford, Cambridge's and Thomson's 1st non-Cambridge research student....When I was working on this article last week, I mixed some citric acid with CuO. It initially produced a blue solution sitting on top of the remaining black oxide. Four days later, a greenish, insoluble solid clung to the walls of the flask. Yesterday i transfered some to a copper plate. I'm hoping for an organic film to bind the copper and the crystals.
    UvaE
    I also noticed that in the J.J.Thomson Building, even the gutter and downspout seem to be made out of copper.
    rholley
    Copper is quite widely used in the earlier (1960s) architecture at Reading U.
     
    Here is another drainpipe outside the Humanities and Social Sciences building (HumSS), formerly the Faculty of Letters, which also has a copper roof.
     
    The main focus of the picture is the ornamental cherry bark (I’m so keen on such pictures that I must be barking mad!), but the drainpipe makes a lovely colour contrast.
     
    Robert H. Olley / Quondam Physics Department / University of Reading / England
    UvaE
    Here's a synthetic patina(?)10 months after I synthesized it from copper oxide and citric acid. The recipe is my own, so I can't guarantee that it's indeed a patina. The picture below also reveals some unreacted CuO coated with the greenish mixture of compounds. If anyone out there can do a free mass spectrographical analysis of the compound for me, it would be deeply appreciated, and I will mail it out.