Just a few years ago, I was a practicing naturopathic
doctor. I considered myself to be a primary care physician who had been trained
in the best of two worlds: supposedly, one was modern medicine and the other
was a mixture of alternative practices based in “ancient wisdom.”
I went to naturopathic school at Bastyr University where my
proclivity to think that natural medicine could greatly improve upon
conventional medicine developed into a fully fledged naturalistic way of life.
It is not unfair to say that my fellow classmates and I were brainwashed. We
believed that we were being trained just like medical doctors but with the
added bonus of learning the secret knowledge of harnessing the healing power of
nature, which could somehow supersede science. I am already having flashbacks
to my homeopathy classes.
By many societal measures, I was a doctor. I held a DEA
number, so when I called in prescriptions to pharmacies I seemed just like
other authorized practitioners. In some cases, I could bill my services to
insurance companies and state health care programs. To many, the “ND” after my
name appeared as a legitimate medical degree. My patients, family, and friends
called me “Doctor Britt.”
I got to that point, it seems, because naturopaths
aggressively lobby for laws to issue them medical licenses. I would
characterize this political effort as a perverted redefinition of the words
“physician,” “doctor,” “medical school,” and “residency” in order to mask the
inadequacy of the training provided in naturopathic programs. ND students do
not realize that they are taking educational shortcuts and therefore do not
possess any demonstrable competencies found in modern medicine. Instead, NDs go
on to make money by fooling themselves that they are legitimate doctors, while
not taking a moment to question the validity of their methods, even in the face
of criticism levied by the scientific community. I didn’t realize that this
sort of parochialism is a defining feature of my former profession until I
unexpectedly found myself in a nerve-rattling situation.
While in practice in Tucson, Arizona, I discovered that my
former boss, a licensed naturopathic doctor, had been importing and
administering a non-FDA approved drug to cancer patients, many of whom were
terminally ill. I had been helping him give various intravenous injections and
drips to many of his patients because his schedule was busy. It turned out that
under his orders I had unwittingly administered this drug to several patients.
The same day I resigned from my practice, I received a call
from a close mentor, who happened to be a former president of the American
Association of Naturopathic Physicians. This friend tried to convince me I
should ignore the advice I had received from my newly hired lawyer to report my
boss’s criminal activity to the regulatory board and state attorney general.
His words suggested that ethical and legal transgressions, like the one before
me, were prevalent in the naturopathic community and tolerated due to the
special kind of medicine we were practicing.
Indeed, his assessment was correct. When I started to look
at licensed naturopaths across North America, I found appalling examples of
professional misconduct and unethical treatments advertised online or discussed
favorably on social media communities. I eventually learned that the drug my
former boss was importing, named ukrain, had a sordid history at the hands of
charlatan chemist in Austria, who is now facing criminal charges of commercial
fraud. My boss ended up with a token punishment of a warning letter. His errant
behavior was not egregious enough for the authorities to revoke or suspend his
license, levy a fine, or require him to return the tens if not hundreds of
thousands of dollars he billed patients. I had to extradite myself from
naturopathy. I had to speak out against this profession.
It is true, I am a bit bitter about being duped into
thinking I was a real doctor. I borrowed over $250,000 in federal loans for a
fake medical education, which, by the way, is how much one can borrow to pay
for real medical school.
Now that I am largely past the heartache of losing friends,
a livelihood, and a quarter of a million dollars, I am trying to be grateful
for my scientific rehabilitation. My accidental involvement in my former boss's
reprehensible activity and being urged to turn a blind eye led me to
re-evaluate my belief system. Prior to this seminal moment, I was skilled at
ignoring information that I did not agree with. Today, I can no longer disregard
the inconvenient fact that I was a quack.
I am currently completing a Master of Science program in
biomedicine, while trying to understand my journey into, and out of, magical
ways of thinking. Along the way, I am exploring why I have a (surprisingly
persistent) bias toward naturalistic philosophies, how to think critically, and
what can be done to educate the public to prevent mistakes resembling mine or
those of my former patients who only wanted to be treated by a doctor like me.
Science 2.0 offers a great platform to raise awareness of
the corruption of the scientific enterprise and epidemic of deluding social
currents towards magical ways of thinking. For example, I often wonder how the
authors of research studies feel about their work being used by alternative
medical practitioners to sell patients on dubious diagnoses and treatments. I
plan to find out and write about it here, among other issues relating to the
interface of quackery with scientific institutions. Having been one of these practitioners
myself, I have a unique perspective to help unravel these pseudoscientific
transactions.
Starting over is hard but not impossible. I’ll take the
challenging work of a science-based career any day over a life acting as a fake
doctor. I hope you will join me as I continue to engage with the world of
science now that I am out of the rabbit hole.
How A Former Naturopath Can Help Unravel The Trickery Of Alternative Medicine
Related articles
- Is Naturopathic Medicine Safe And Effective? Leading Naturopathic Researchers Cannot Even Say
- Are Naturopaths Fooling Themselves?
- H1N1 Swine Flu: How it feels to have the dreaded "Pandemic Flu". Don't Panic.
- Dr. Arnold Relman Takes On Industry Support Of Medical Education (again)
- After Andreas Lubitz, Should Pilots Have Less Medical Privacy?
Comments