A new stem cell paper has just come out in Cell from Harvard in this area. It reports making insulin-producing β cells from human embryonic stem cells (hESC) with the notion of some day using these cells to treat Diabetes. See graphical abstract at right from the paper. These β cells help Diabetic mice control their blood sugar.
No doubt this is an exciting paper, but one that the media has for the most part hyped to an extreme. For example, they often used the word "cure" related to this paper, which at this point is way over the top.
For a balanced, well-researched newspaper article on this Harvard Diabetes research I recommend this piece by John Lauerman at Bloomberg. It's also worth noting that the same Harvard team published another big Cell paper related to stem cells and Diabetes last year on a hormone they discovered called Betatrophin that stimulates cells to turn into β cells.
Here are my top 10 key take home messages for this new paper in the context of the larger field of stem cell-related Diabetes research.
- There are many labs around the world working on research toward the goal of using stem cells as a basis to treat Diabetes. The Harvard work is notable, but should be discussed in this larger context.
- For example, another entity, the privately held stem cell biotech ViaCyte, has an approved IND for an hESC-based Diabetes treatment and an approved device in the form of a capsule.
- Harvard will also need some kind of capsulation technology/device, which it does not appear to have at present. Harvard team leader Doug Melton described such a needed device as a "tea bag" with the idea being that the cells inside sense blood sugar (which goes into the capsule from blood) and make insulin (which goes out into the blood), but no cells should be able to go in or out.
- ViaCyte will start a clinical trial in as soon as a few months for their hESC-based Diabetes therapy.
- Barring some major change in regulatory approach by the FDA, the Harvard stem cell Diabetes product probably won't start to be tested in humans for at least about 4 years given the experiences of other groups using human embryonic stem cell-based products. It's important to keep expectations realistic.
- Going back to 2006 we find a Nature Biotechnology paper using hESC to make pancreatic progenitor cells that can turn into β cells and other kinds of pancreatic cells, work from a team led by Ed Baetge of Novocell (now ViaCyte). Only now is ViaCyte going to start their in-human trials. These things take time.
- ViaCyte's product is not pure β cells, while the Harvard product appears to be relatively pure β cells. This could prove to be an important advantage over ViaCyte's approach in the long run.
- A challenge for any stem cell-based product is potential immune rejection by the patient given that Type I Diabetes has an immune component as a disease and the fact that the product will be allogeneic.
- What works in mice often doesn't work in humans so caution is in order.
- Whether talking about Harvard or ViaCyte or anyone else, it is way premature for the media to talk about "cures" for Diabetes. The most appropriate word to use is "treatment".
A version of this piece was first published at www.ipscell.com