A new simulation modeled the effects of land use changes on the species diversity in rivers and streams and estimates that the loss of biodiversity will caused by changes in land use practices far more than by climate change.

Despite that, climate change gets all of the attention and changing land use practices, such as clear-cutting of forests for agricultural use, are frequently neglected in the development of conservation concepts.

From source to mouth, rivers and streams are in constant motion and count among the world’s most dynamic ecosystems. Although they only cover a small percentage of the land area, in their natural state these ecosystems are home to a multitude of living organisms: insects, fish, algae, bivalves and daphnias are but a few of the denizens of streams and rivers.

“At the same time, however, rivers and streams are the most endangered ecosystems on a global scale,” according Dr. Mathias Kuemmerlen from the Department of Freshwater Ecology and Nature Conservation Research at the Research Institute Senckenberg in Gelnhausen. He adds, “Rivers and streams are more sensitive to environmental changes than any other biotope.”

He and colleagues studied the rivers and streams in a catchment area of approximately 1,700 square kilometers in Southern China, which is part of the drainage basin of the Yangtze River. “For the first time, we modeled a future projection of the species diversity in connection with land use changes,” explains Dr. Sonja Jähnig, who conducts research at the Leibniz Institute for Freshwater Ecology and Inland Fisheries in Berlin and who initiated this study. She adds, “The loss of biodiversity is often studied in relation to climate change. Other important anthropogenic impacts on the environment – such as changing land use practices – are frequently neglected in this context.”

The scientists modeled three scenarios for the development of freshwater-dwelling macroinvertebrates – animals without a vertebral column easily recognized with the naked eye – for the years from 2021 until 2050: the climate change, the change in land use, and a combined climate change and land use change scenario. The 72 aquatic organisms that were studied display a wide range of different behaviors in the models. In the course of land use changes, the aquatic stonefly Togoperla sp. stands to lose 85 percent of its distribution area in the studied drainage basin and is locally threatened with extinction, while damselfly species of the family Protoneuridae gain an additional 9 percent of potential habitat.

“In all of our models, there are ‘losers’ and ‘winners,’ both in the land use and climate change scenarios. However, across all species, it can be said that the changes in land use have the strongest negative effect on the species diversity in rivers and streams – in this model, the local biodiversity decreased by 20 percent,” explains Kuemmerlen.

In the scientists’ models, the effect of climate change on the biodiversity in rivers and streams is only of secondary importance. According to Kuemmerlen,

“There is a close interaction between flowing water and the landscapes in the drainage basin. Therefore, the species diversity is strongly affected by land use practices.”

In addition, the modeling results show that the combined effect of changes in land use and climate may lead to a general decrease in local species diversity. Moreover, a shift in the distributions of many aquatic invertebrates can be expected.

Citation: Kuemmerlen, M., Schmalz, B., Cai, Q., Haase, P., Fohrer, N. and Jähnig, S. C. (2015), An attack on two fronts: predicting how changes in land use and climate affect the distribution of stream macroinvertebrates. Freshwater Biology. doi: 10.1111/fwb.12580