A recent Northwestern University study has a surprising results - substantially more men are likely to share their creative work online than women even though both genders engage in creative activities at essentially equal rates.
Even more surprising - the researchers think that's ... unfair.
Overall, almost two-thirds of men reported posting their work online while only half of women reported doing so. When Eszter Hargittai, assistant professor of communication studies at Northwestern University, and Northwestern's Gina Walejko controlled for self-reported digital literacy and Web know-how, however, they found that men and women actually posted their material about equally.
The study titled "The Participation Divide: Content Creation and Sharing in the Digital Age recently appeared in the journal Information, Communication and Society.
Hargittai and Walejko found men were more than twice as likely to share music on the Web that they had created or re-mixed than were women; and that men were also considerably more likely to post film or video they made when compared to women who engaged in film- or video-making.
"Because sharing information on the Internet today is a form of participating in public culture and contributing to public discourse, that means men's voices are being disproportionately heard," says Hargittai. "This suggests that the Internet is not an equal playing field for men and women since those with more online abilities -- whether perceived or actual -- are more likely to contribute online content."
Yes, that sounds like they are contending the internet should have gender quotas. Or that women don't know how to use computers.
"It appears that lack of perceived skill is holding women back from putting their creative content out there," says Hargittai.
She also says that other factors that may be responsible for the observed difference, although not measured in the study, may relate to lack of confidence in the quality of one's work or privacy concerns.
"Much of the early research about the Web dwelled on accessibility and on digital technology's 'haves' and 'have-nots,'" says Hargittai. And early conversations about the Web revolved around its potential as a social leveler once access issues were resolved.
In their survey of creative content -- whether online or offline -- the Northwestern researchers found that on average two out of three men and two out of three women engage in creative writing, art photography, music or film/video generally (and this does not relate in any way to the Web).
"So while creative output, on the aggregate, is equally distributed among men and women, the sharing of such content is not," Hargittai says.
Of the 61 percent of the full sample who reported engaging in at least one type of creative activity, 56 percent said they posted at least some of their creative work online.
Not surprisingly -- since it is the easiest content to post -- the most popular type of creative content shared online was creative writing. Just over half of the students who report engaging in creative writing also reported posting their work online.
Video was the second most popular creative work to be posted, at just under 50 percent. Again, Hargittai points to the ease of posting such material. "Video-sharing sites like YouTube make it relatively simple for people to share their own or remixed videos," she says.
The Northwestern researchers' study was based on a survey of 1,060 freshmen from the University of Illinois, Chicago, which, according to U.S. News & World Report, is one of the nation's most ethnically diverse universities. The researchers observed little-to-no difference in the posting habits of students from different racial and ethnic backgrounds.
The study is part of a series of studies by Web Use Project that is funded by the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation through the Foundation's Digital Media and Learning Initiative. Northwestern's Web Use Project also looks at how online skill differences influence Web user behavior and how young adults benefit from time spent using digital media.