What does peer review do for science and what does the scientific community want it to do? Should peer review detect fraud and misconduct? Does peer review illuminate good ideas or shut them down? Should reviewers be anonymous?
The Peer Review Survey 2009, a large international poll of authors and reviewers, released its preliminary findings today.
Peer review is considered fundamental to integration of new research findings and it allows other researchers to analyze findings and society at large to weigh up research claims. It results in 1.3 million2 articles published every year and it has been growing rapidly with the expansion of the global research community - and corporate publishers.