Females don't always think bigger is better when it comes to males. Instead, it is just the opposite, in some instances. Females may be more attracted to small partners because they are less likely to get into fights.
In many species large males have more mating success than small males, either because females find them more attractive or because they can use their brawn to intimidate small rivals. They are also more likely to have more sexual partners and be less committed fathers.
A study in the Journal of Evolutionary Biology found that while small male beetles were more successful at attracting female mates to the breeding ground of an animal carcass than larger males, they didn't make better parents. Researchers tested whether individual male burying beetles -- known for being exceptionally good parents in the insect world -- would help look after their current family for longer if they had clues that it might be difficult to find, or compete for, other mates.
The male beetles were placed in the wild with a dead mouse, an ideal place for them to mate and rear a family, and where they called for mates by releasing pheromones.
Unexpectedly, small males were more successful than large males at attracting a female partner to the carcass than a male rival, and researchers believe that this is because they attracted less competition and potential for squabbles.
Dr. Paul Hopwood of the Centre for Ecology and Conservation at the University of Exeter's Penryn Campus, Cornwall, and lead researcher on the project, said, "These results show that by being choosy about their males, female burying beetles might avoid complicated relationships involving male fights and extra female competitors."
The research allowed male burying beetles to grow up and mature in the laboratory in groups with different ratios of males and females. This was to give individual males clues to the likely competition they might face, and the availability of females in the future before placing them with a carcass in the wild. The findings showed that when the first beetle to arrive was female both beetles quickly settled down and bred as a pair. However, when a male turned up first, relationships got complicated and messy, when competition from other males led to fights.
The apparent allure of small males also led to them breeding more often in 'faithful' pairs than larger males. In this case small males were more attractive but did not respond by being better parents. "We found no evidence that males of any size, or from any social background, were more committed parents," added Dr Hopwood.