We all know about people’s personalities, and anyone with a dog or a cat will also tell you about their temperaments. More surprising, though, is how many others, from octopuses to frogs and even spiders have them. So why behave according to a personality, when flexibility could allow smarter choices?
A study by Portuguese researchers now exploits an original approach - where the invasion of a territory by common waxbills is proxy for the bird evolution over time – to find that the emergence of different personalities can be linked to climate variation. The work reveals that in regions with more variable climate, birds explore less autonomously and are more attentive to their peers, than those in areas with a more stable weather. “This is probably because” – says Carlos Carvalho the first author of the research - “with resources and food more unpredictable, social learning, in opposition to bold exploration, allows better informed choices increasing the animals chances of success”.
For a long time animal personalities were seen as random variation by researchers worried of anthropomorphism accusations. But with the discovery that the behavioural differences were often for life and extremely common, the scientific world's interest was eventually triggered. Researchers went to discover that animal personality comprised traits very similar to ours, from aggressiveness and boldness to docility, sociability and cooperativeness. But the reason why these different temperaments co-existed within a species remained less clear. Ultimately, a flexible behaviour should allow animals to adapt better and, consequently, improve survival as well. So what is the point of fixed ones (personalities)
Using a recent invasion in Portugal of the common waxbill (Estrilda astrild) in the work now published, Carvalho, Gonçalo and colleagues attempt to answer this question. Waxbills are small birds native to Sub-Sarah Africa, which, due to their popularity as pets and escape from captivity, are now everywhere. Their Portuguese colonization is recent, around 40 years, but particularly well documented - from the climate and ecology of the different colonized environments, to the size and age of the different waxbill populations. The scientists’ idea was to use the birds’ expansion as a simulacrum for their evolution over time and, with the help of the colonization data, search for links between behavior/personality and ecology
Analysis of various waxbill populations discovered that personality differences emerge rapidly, with birds in areas with more variable climates exploring less and responding more to social stimuli than those in more stable weather conditions. This suggested that they relied more on cues from the other animals in what seemed to be an adaptation to their unstable environment. After all different individuals vary in their abilities and experience so to be attentive to conspecifics should increase the efficiency of problem solving and a good idea in unpredictable environments.
In more stable environments, however, the birds could afford a “not think much” approach and make decisions based on past experiences. Having a fast response had the advantage of making them more competitive even if the chances of obsolete responses increased. This was not much of a problem though since in stable environments the location of food and resources is more predictable.
The next step was to investigate how the different behaviors emerge. “They didn’t change with age or season suggesting a genetic or long-term developmental basis ” - explains Cardoso the senior scientist in the study - “ So, we investigated a gene known to be implicated in avian personality but could find nothing.”
This, however, still does not invalidate a genetic cause behind waxbills’ personalities – after all not only genetic influences tend to be the sum of many genes, but also behavioral genetic is still much in its infancy with much (other genes) to be found.
In conclusion, since environmental changes (in this case climate) can cause populations to rapidly diverge in personality, then environmental fluctuations over time (very common in nature) are probably an important factor contributing to keep a mix of distinct temperaments within populations.
Understand what determines behavioural changes in animals is important for animal management and conservation but Gonçalo Cardoso points that the results can be relevant for humans as well.
“The study of animal behaviour allows us to ask questions that would be much more difficult to test with human personality, because cultural adaptations can make it hard to demonstrate the underlying biological and psychological influences. For an extreme example, think of those hyperactive children that, like the waxbills in more stable environments, are impetuous and less motivated towards conventional social learning – could animal behaviour help us understand this type of diversity among people too?”
Behavioral Ecology May 2013 doi:10.1093/beheco/art034, Personality traits are related to ecology across a biological invasion, Carlos F. Carvalho, Ana V. Leitão, Caterina Funghi, Helena R. Batalha, Sandra Reis, Paulo Gama Mota, Ricardo J. Lopes and Gonçalo C. Cardoso, http://beheco.oxfordjournals.org