Everyone issues forth platitudes about how science should be more 'open' and, in a world of social media, it will certainly stay harder to remain closed.
A few weeks ago, a leak about a possible new discovery (for the comprehensive explanation from a member of the collaboration, see Tommaso Dorigo) set the media aflame. A preliminary document seemed to show γ-rays from a decaying Higgs particle with a mass of 115 gigaelectronvolts and the details about what it really or really was are best left to experts like Tommaso but the issue here is, will open science, part of the Science 2.0 vision, make any headway or not?
More importantly, what if the information is not released by a blogger but perhaps extracted by a journalist? New Scientist, no stranger to controversy to pump up readership, came forth with its own leak a few days later, this from a Powerpoint slideshow they apparently got by having access to an internal username and password for the Compact Muon Solenoid (CMS) detector group, the complement to ATLAS. The press were rather quick to ignore the second one but the issue will remain, how open is open?
It's one thing to share private lab data but a collaboration and their reputations would prefer to exercise stronger control and verification before results are leaked - especially since, in the case of the ATLAS leak, it seemed to be more that some physicists got too little sleep and too much excitement.
Subscribe to the newsletter
[x]
Stay in touch with the scientific world!
Know Science And Want To Write?
Apply for a column: writing@science20.com
Donate or Buy SWAG
Please donate so science experts can write
for the public.
At Science 2.0, scientists are the journalists,
with no political bias or editorial control. We
can't do it alone so please make a difference.
We are a nonprofit science journalism
group operating under Section 501(c)(3)
of the Internal Revenue Code that's
educated over 300 million people.
You can help with a tax-deductible
donation today and 100 percent of your
gift will go toward our programs,
no salaries or offices.
- California Politicians Lower The 'Erin Brockovich' Chemical And Cheer Saving 0 Lives
- Vaccines Have Saved 101 Million Infants In 50 Years, Europe Needs To Let That Happen In Agriculture Too
- Biden's Nursing Home Mandate Will Do To Rural Senior Care What Obamacare Did To Hospitals
- Oil Kept Congo From Starving - Western Academics Don't Seem To Like That
- California Is Lying About Recycling Plastic: Happy Earth Day
- EPA Debunks Environmentalist Claims That Acephate Causes Autism
- Despite Little Demand, 2024 Electric Car Sales Will Be Up To 17 Million, Says Advocacy Group
Interesting insights from outside Science 2.0
© 2024 Science 2.0
Comments