The evolution game Spore was somewhat of a critical flop - especially among scientists. The game has glitzy graphics, but, for a game billed as being somehow connected to science, the science sucked. What's more important, many of us thought the game play could have been improved with better science.
Well, if the Spore guys had gotten together with the creator of
Swimbots, (or GenePool - not sure which is the real name) the result might have been amazing graphics, gameplay, and science: