In response, a group of scientists from the United Kingdom, United States, Australia and Indonesia have written a discussion paper in which they claim to refute the main arguments made by Lapindo Brantas and document new data that provides the strongest evidence to date of a link between the well and the volcano. That paper will be published in the same journal.
"The disaster was caused by pulling the drill string and drill bit out of the hole while the hole was unstable," lead author of the paper challenging the earthquake explanation Richard Davies, director of the Durham Energy Institute, said. "This triggered a very large 'kick' in the well, where there is a large influx of water and gas from surrounding rock formations that could not be controlled.
Crater Aeriel view (courtesy of Channel 9 Australia)
"We found that one of the on-site daily drilling reports states that Lapindo Brantas pumped heavy drilling mud into the well to try to stop the mud volcano. This was partially successful and the eruption of the mud volcano slowed down. The fact that the eruption slowed provides the first conclusive evidence that the bore hole was connected to the volcano at the time of eruption."
The Durham University-led group of scientists believe that their analysis resolves the cause beyond all reasonable doubt. According to their discussion paper, 'The pumping of heavy mud caused a reduction in the rate of flow to the surface. The reason for pumping the mud was to stop the flow by increasing the pressure exerted by the mud column in the well and slowing the rate of flux of fluid from surrounding formations.'
"An earthquake trigger can be ruled out because the earthquake was too small given its distance, and the stresses produced by the earthquake were minute smaller than those created by tides and weather," said co-author Michael Manga, professor of earth and planetary science at the University of California, Berkeley.
The group of scientists has identified five critical drilling errors as the causes of the Lusi mud volcano eruption:
- having a significant open hole section with no protective casing
- overestimating the pressure the well could tolerate
- after complete loss of returns, the decision to pull the drill string out of an extremely unstable hole
- pulling the bit out of the hole while losses were occurring
- not identifying the kick more rapidly
"This is the clearest evidence uncovered so far that the Lusi mud volcano was triggered by drilling," Davies said. "We have detailed data collected over two years that show the events that led to the creation of the Lusi volcano."
"The observation that pumping mud into the hole caused a reduction in eruption rate indicates a direct link between the wellbore and the eruption," he added. "The decision was made to pull the drill bit out of the hole without verifying that a stable mud column was in place and it was done while severe circulating mud losses were in progress. This procedure caused the kick."
The Lusi volcano, which first erupted on May 29, 2006, in the Porong sub-district of Sidoarjo, close to Indonesia's second city of Surabaya, East Java, now covers seven square kilometers – nearly three square miles and is 20 meters (65 feet) thick. The mud flow has razed four villages and 25 factories. Thirteen people have died as a result of a rupture in a natural gas pipeline underneath one of the holding dams.
The Lusi crater has been oozing enough mud to fill 50 Olympic size swimming pools every day. All efforts to stem the mud flow have failed, including the construction of dams, levees, drainage channels, and even plugging the crater with concrete balls. Lusi may continue to erupt for decades, scientists believe.
Arguments over the causes of the Lusi volcano have stalled the establishment of liability for the disaster and delayed compensation to thousands of people affected by the mud. The Yogyakarta earthquake that occurred at the time of the volcano was cited by some as a possible cause of the eruption, but the research team rejected this explanation.