Banner
    This Is Your Brain On Art
    By Kathy Murphy | May 14th 2009 08:14 PM | 4 comments | Print | E-mail | Track Comments
    About Kathy

    Kathy Murphy is a Neuroscientist studying the impact of early experience on neuroplasticity of the developing brain. Kathy is the Founder and Director...

    View Kathy's Profile
    Have you ever thought about what's going on in your brain when you look at a painting that you like a lot?  While Neuroscientist Dr. Edward Vessel has and he's done brain imaging experiments to figure it out.

    What happens in your brain when you have a pleasurable experience -- for example, when you see at a painting that you like very much.  Scientists describe this as an aesthetically pleasing experience.  They want to know if simply seeing a painting that you enjoy engages an emotional response and triggers the emotion circuits in your brain.

    Neuroscientists have shown that our brain responds fastest to what a painting is about, is it a portrait or a landscape.  And a bit slower to recognize the style of the painting, is it abstract or impressionism.  But Dr Ed Vessel a Neuroscientist at New York University's Center for Brain Imaging asked a different question.  He wanted to know how seeing a painting makes us feel

    What's going on in our brain when we have a strong emotional response to seeing a painting?   This is a very old question and one that artists ask all the time.   Will my painting evoke an emotional response when someone looks at it?

    This week at the Vision Science Society meeting in Naples Florida, Dr Vessel reported the results of his brain imaging study designed to find out what goes on in our brain when we look at an aesthetically pleasing piece of art.  He showed subjects paintings and asked them to  rate the paintings from 1 to 4.  Subjects were told that they were helping an art curator decide which paintings to include in an art exhibit and to rate a painting as 1 if they didn't like it, and 4 if they liked it a lot.  The subjects looked at the different paintings and gave the ratings while in an MRI machine so that the responses in their brain could be imaged.

    An interesting thing happened when the subjects saw a painting that they liked a lot.  Those painting evoked a different response in their brains.  There was a very strong response in multiple areas -- the left medial prefrontal cortex, left substantial nigra, and left hippocampus.  Brain areas that span regions involved in higher order cognitive processing, emotion, and memory.  A large and diverse array of neural areas.

    Each subject picked different paintings as the most pleasing.  But the responses in the brain were the same.  The same set of regions in the brain responded to the paintings that they liked the best.   This means that it is how the paintings made the subject feel rather than something simple like the colors in the paintings, that drove these response in the brain.

    Dr Vessel said "a rating of 4 really engaged our subjects a lot".   For Ed Vessel, these systems are engaged when he sees one of his favorite paintings, the Chinese Restaurant by Max Weber.  

    the Chinese Restaurant by Max Weber

    The meaning of the painting is the most important factor for the response in the brain.  When subjects saw a painting that they thought was beautiful there was a very strong response.  Vessel said "the prefrontal cortical areas seem to integrate the emotional and aesthetic reaction to looking at these paintings".

    These studies give us a new appreciation for what's going on in the brain when we see something that we like.  And show that just seeing something beautiful engages a wide range of cognitive, emotion, and memory circuits in the brain.

    For more information you can look at Dr Edward Vessel's website.

    Comments

    I am an artist and would love to get a better understanding of this research. Is it possible to contract. Edward A. Vessel.

    kmmuffy
    Hi Peter

    There is a link for Dr Vessel at the end of the article.  You can find his contact information on his web page.
    "the prefrontal cortical areas seem to integrate the emotional and aesthetic reaction to looking at these paintings"
    I'd like to cite this in my dissertation, which of his works did you get it from?? I've looked all through his page and this is your brain on art etc.
    If you could get back to me as soon as possible I'd be so grateful, the dissertations due quite soon
    Thanks a lot, great article

    The fact that you use words like "they thought was beautiful", shows that you and, most likely, your subjects do not know what art really is. Art is not a beautiful picture or a beautiful painting. True art stimulates a part of my brain that is separate from just pretty pictures. I can look at various pictures and pick out which are really art and which are just pictures. Often what I consider "art" is not something that makes me feel good. My favorite piece of art that I saw in a British museum, was a painting of a queen just before being beheaded. The painting made me very sad, it was not pleasing, and it was not beautiful. Never-the-less I consider it the best piece of art I have ever seen in my entire life. I do not think you have discovered the brains reaction to art, as you have discovered the brains response to beautiful images. I recommend you consult with true connoisseurs of art to continue your studies, as most people do not truly know what real art is.