Work-hour caps for surgical residents designed to lessen complication rates have not accomplished that. Instead, the period after work-hour limits were introduced saw an uptick in complication rates , according to findings which raise concerns that limiting residents' work hours isn't really a benefit.
The analysis was designed to evaluate the patient safety impact of rules limiting the hours worked by residents, a measure introduced in 2003. The goal of the limits, a maximum of 88 hours per week, was to reduce the risk of errors and injury related to resident fatigue.
The researchers analyzed data from a nationwide hospital database from 1998-2002 and 2004-2008, five years before and five years after the new work-hour rules. The study focused on surgery to remove benign brain tumors called meningiomas—a common neurosurgery procedure that did not significantly change in other ways during the periods studied. Complication rates were assessed for more than 21,000 patients. The study looked at complications not only at teaching hospitals where residents work and train, but also in non-teaching hospitals, which don't train residents.
The data from teaching hospitals showed a significant increase in complication rates after the work-hour limits were introduced: from 14 percent in 1998-2002 to 16 percent in 2004-2008. In contrast, complication rates at non-teaching hospitals remained "nearly constant"—fifteen percent during both time periods. The increase in complications at teaching hospitals remained significant after adjustment for other known risk factors—especially age and medical illnesses.
Limiting Duty Hours - The Ongoing Debate
Doctors are not like everyone else. They want to work. A lot. The findings add a new piece of evidence to the ongoing debate over the impact of work-hour limits, particularly for neurosurgery residents. Last year, Neurosurgery published a survey study which found that neurosurgery trainees strongly opposed the new limits because they felt that working fewer hours had a negative effect on their training opportunities. You don't get that kind of motivated response in government-run health care.
The new analysis shows that, at least for one common neurosurgery procedure, limiting residents' work hours has not increased patient safety. Instead, complication rates actually increased in the years after the new rules were introduced.
Has the increase in complications occurred because residents have less surgical experience? Not necessarily, according to the authors. Other factors, especially age and medical illness, remain strong predictors of complications. Yet it's possible that the limits could have affected risk in other ways—possibly by leading to "increased patient hand-offs, decreased continuity of care, and thus [increased] errors related to postoperative patient care."
"We would not argue with the idea that fatigue or sleep deprivation contribute to decreases in performance, but the relative contributions of these factors must be carefully weighed against the perhaps more pervasive effects of increased patient hand-offs, increased provider turnover, and decreased familiarity with patients, " says Dr. Anand I. Rughani, of the University of Toronto, co-author of the paper.
The coauthors believe their study "raises questions about the relationship between work-hour restrictions and clinical care." They discuss the results in light of other studies showing decreased "academic productivity" by residents—including lower performance on written exams. The researchers conclude, "It could be argued that duty-hour regulation has exerted a common influence across the spectrum of academic, scientific, and clinical activities and performance."
Published in Neurosurgery
It's Complicated: Work Hour Limits For Surgical Residents Don't Reduce Risk
- You Knew This- Surgeons Who Practice Are Better At It
- Reducing Resident Hours May Have Unintended Negative Effects
- Heart Attack Paradox: For Some, It's Better When The Cardiologist Is At A Convention
- Infection Is The Leading Cause Of Failed Prosthetic Knee Joints
- Canadian Stroke Victims More Likely To Die On Weekends