"In 1934, L.E.Kinsler at the California Institute of technology was studying the Zeeman effect as a means for evaluating the charge-to-mass ratio of the electron, e/m. The deduction of e/m from the measured wavelength differences involves, in addition to a high-precision measurement of the magnetic field, a knowledge of the way in which the individual electron spins and orbital angular momenta are coupled. However, there are certain quantities or combinations of quantities that are independent of the nature of the coupling. One such combination is provided for by a relation called the g-sum rule, which states that the sum of the values of for all the states with a given value of J formed from a given combination of single-electron states is independent of the coupling. Kinsler undertook to test this rule, using two states in neon that involved five electrons in 2p states and one in a 3s state.[...]
Kinsler's measurements gave , .
The discrepancies from the values are substantial but are presumably to be ascribed to the imperfectness of the L-S description. The g-sum rule is another matter: .
Kinsler simply added the errors on the individual values and quoted a resultant error of 0.0016, so that the discrepancy was regarded as insignificant. [...] If the individual errors were independent, a better overall uncertainty would have been the square root of the sum of the squares, or 0.0011, making the discrepancy large enough to be taken seriously. [...]
Even if Kinsler had believed his result, however, the tone of his paper suggests that he would have ascribed it to the failure of the g-sum rule rather than to an anomalous value of . On such minor things does the course of events depend!"
George L. Trigg, Landmark Experiments in Twentieth Century Physics, Crane (NY) 1975.
- PHYSICAL SCIENCES
- EARTH SCIENCES
- LIFE SCIENCES
- SOCIAL SCIENCES
Subscribe to the newsletter
Stay in touch with the scientific world!
Know Science And Want To Write?
- New Results From The LHC At 13 TeV!
- How Did Mexico Eliminate Breast Cancer Deaths?
- Will Aspartame Critics Now Be Less Bitter?
- Half Of Biomedical Studies Aren't Reproducible – And What We Need To Do About That
- The Science Behind Distillation
- No other way
- High Z: Metal Foams Shield X-rays, Gamma Rays And Neutron Radiation
- "Please disclose any funding ACSH receives from the beverage industry, it is certainly relevant..."
- "This cat (top picture) used to roam our neighbourhood, visiting our garden regularly over about..."
- "Nice! But please don't call Lise Meitner the mother of the atom bomb - she always hated that phrase..."
- "Question: Are there 2 data points missing in the mT plot? and surely the high mT 'excess' has got..."
- "I think Omoo is a fine word. But Pluto may not like it regardless, because 2% of astronomers may..."