Banner
    The Unusual Case Of The Man With The Green Blood
    By Cash Simpson | June 8th 2007 09:40 AM | 13 comments | Print | E-mail | Track Comments
    A new novel about Sherlock Holmes or, my favorite, The Saint?

    No, this really happened in an operating room in St Paul’s Hospital, British Columbia. Dr. Alana Flexman, Dr. Stephan Schwarz and Dr. Giuseppe Del Vicario wrote the case report.

    The patient, a 42-year-old white Canadian, had developed nerve damage due to restricted blood flow in his lower legs after falling asleep in a sitting position. He was a smoker and his medical history included chronic shoulder pain and migraine headaches. He was was taking a number of prescription medications, including Sumatriptan for the migraines.

    To save his lower legs from damage they decided to do fasciotomies, where the tissue is cut to relieve pressure. They performed a battery of emergency tests and his blood pressure was normal. He did have high Creatine Kinase concentration and a rapid heart beat. Creatine Kinase is an important enzyme in tissue repair and high levels usually mean damage to muscle while very low levels might mean alcoholic liver disease or rheumatoid arthritis.

    Still, nothing critical, his toxicology screen was negative and surgery was approved. In the operating room is when things got strange. When doctors tried to place a catheter in the radial artery, his blood came out ... green.

    Off to the lab his blood went.

    There's a condition called cyanosis,when the blood cannot bind oxygen and this means the blood is also not properly delivering oxygen to tissues. It creates a blue color in skin.

    But the classic case of cyanosis results from deoxyhemoglobin, a lack of oxygen in the blood. Less often it is caused by high methemoglobin which differs from normal hemoglobin in that the oxygen-carrying ferrous iron in the heme groups has been oxidized to the ferric iron. His methemoglobin concentration was normal. Plus, cyanosis caused by methemoglobinemia usually results in brown- or chocolate-colored blood that does not become red when exposed to oxygen. It isn't green.

    They turned to the rare sulfhemoglobinemia, rather than classic cyanosis, as the cause of the green-black blood. Sulfhemoglobinemia happens when a sulphur atom is incorporated into the hemoglobin molecule, and it can be caused by medications, including sulfonamides, which were present in the sumatriptan the patient had been taking for migraine headaches.

    Did the sumatriptan create the green blood?

    Said Flexman, "The triptans used to treat migraine have never been reported to cause sulfhemoglobinemia. I would also like to stress that we can in no way prove that sumatriptan was the cause of his sulfhemoglobinemia. In our case sumatriptan was a possibility, because it contains a sulfonamide group and sulfonamides have been reported to cause sulfhemoglobinemia."

    So the real mystery is not sumatriptan or even green blood, it's sulfhemoglobinemia. Even in a source as extensive as Wikipedia, there is no entry.

    "Typically sulfhemoglobinemia (what little we know) is caused by medications," said Flexman.

    I looked to Dr. Mustafa Noor and Dr. Ernest Beutler of Scripps Clinic in La Jolla, CA, who authored a paper called Acquired sulfhemoglobinemia. An underreported diagnosis?. They wrote that sulfhemoglobinemia and methemoglobinemia are confused because the causes are often the same but the distinction is critical because patients who are mistakenly treated for methemoglobinemia can actually acquire cyanosis from the wrong medication.



    Making the distinction more difficult, as both studies stated, is that not all automated blood-gas analyzers can detect sulfhemoglobinemia because sulfhemoglobin has peak absorption at 620 nm, below the 660-940nm wavelengths in conventional pulse oximetry.

    Things worked out okay for our green-blooded Canadian friend. He recovered without incident, stopped taking the sumatriptan, and after 5 weeks had no trace of sulfhemoglobin.

    He's doing fine and he has a great story to tell, even if Sherlock Holmes himself couldn't solve the mystery of the man with green blood.

    Comments

    This guy was an alien and there is a cover up behind this. You really think we are stupid? There is no other known case of this supposed desease and nowhere in any medical library where they speak of this desease does it ever mention the patient having green blood. I'd say that would be a huge thing to leave out. Regardless, the fact that there are no quotes directly from any of the original doctors is very odd to me too. Suddenly the next day at St. Pauls there are doctors from California taking over the case and they are from a biomedical fascility in California that is funded by the Bush family. Hmmmm can you smell the bs??

    "Hmmmm can you smell the bs??"

    I sure can smell yours.

    I think I'll have to amen your comment. You could grow a lot of roses with that much b.s.

    Hank
    You think The Lancet is controlled by the Bush family and using the Canadian health system as a front?  Are they operating out of a secret mountain lair with the Rothschilds?   Or Antarctica with Col. Sanders?
    Want more no-nonsense, independent science? Buy Science Left Behind
    yeah a reptilian!!!!!! i have herd about this man

    The fact that you guys are even commenting on this page which had NO COMMENTS before then suddenly on the same day that I say something, 1 hour later you are already trying to defuse my bomb. I should correct myself though, that same biomedical laboratory that analyzed the green blood was in direct negotiations with Jeb Bush regarding opening up a second facility in Florida. I am aware of the Lancet's existence as a medical journal. Who says the Bush family controls the Lancet? Apply critical reading skills and then respond to what I actually said. Don't twist my words. It makes you look uneducated and stupid.

    Hank
    The fact that you guys are even commenting on this page which had NO COMMENTS before then suddenly on the same day that I say something, 1 hour later you are already trying to defuse my bomb.
    When this article was written in 2007 there was no comment tracker or recent comments section - now there is so people saw it.   Is your raging paranoia now in belief that the Bush family is monitoring the Internet for when you say something goofy and sends people in just to respond?   Is this part of some Manchurian Candidate thing where entire sites awaken when someone responds to a certain comment on a certain article?
    Want more no-nonsense, independent science? Buy Science Left Behind
    It had no comments because no one thought it was controversial. It was interesting, not paradigm-shattering. You're the one being controversial, not the blog post. You look uneducated and stupid. Medicine is far from a completed field of study, because medical anomalies are encountered quite often. It takes more than an instance of green blood to make an extraterrestrial.

    I have a copy of this article from yesterday, prior to any comments being posted. There are 2 paragraphs that are now present in this article that are not present in the article that i have saved. The article has been changed! I can assure you that this is not the end of this. Im onto something and you know it as well as I do. Goodbye Hank.

    In my original post I stated that it was odd that there were no quotes from the original doctors. There are now quotes from the original doctors....That's change #1.
    Change #2: The mention of cyanosis is not in my original copy of this article.
    Change #3:The mention that cyanosis caused by methemoglobinemia usually results in brown- or chocolate-colored blood and that it isn't green, was also not in my original copy of this article. That information was only found untampered web pages that were not related to this specific case.
    Looks like you guys are working really hard at keeping things underwraps.
    Note to PB: I notice that you respond to my comments after me but somehow they magically appear prior to mine.
    Looks like Hanks got a partner.
    Isnt odd how now there is an entry for sulfhemoglobinemia now in Wikipedia but the only case it mentions is this one regarding green blood. I wonder if suddenly there will be another example on wikipedia. You better get your top guys on that right away. Another hole in your story - youd better patch it up.

    Hank
    Now you claim someone edited the article after your comment to include things you got made fun of for never noticing were there in the first place?  Why would we care again?   About 40 of us can see the edit history of anything on the site and this hasn't been touched since, no surprise, 2007.
    Want more no-nonsense, independent science? Buy Science Left Behind
    Yep, I realize you are convering your tracks, however we have the original article right here on disk.

    WOW, Well I see you guys took care of the wikipedia problem! Now suddenly another person is "THOUGHT" to have sulfahemoglobinemia. Except when I did extensive research on William Thomson, 1st Baron Kelvin, his cause of death is "UNKNOWN" as well, there is NO MENTION of him possibly having had this desease. Another made up thing. Its funny how I am helping you guys with all your holes in this story. I dont know if HANK CAMPBELL is personally responsible for all these changes in this story in the last few months but I certainly know that SOMEONE is trying so hard to keep this story washed in lies. It just makes me feel good that IM SMARTER THAN ALL OF YOU.