...reductionism will never be able to account for the role of historical contingency and accident. Even if an all-powerful being could account for all biological scenarios emerging from an initial state of the universe, it could never tell us why one particular scenario is preferred over others...evolutionary accidents by definition cannot be predicted from starting conditions because they depend on chance and opportunity.
In addition function can never be uniquely derived from reductionism even if structure is. For instance in his book "Reinventing the Sacred", the complexity theorist Stuart Kauffman makes a powerful argument that even if one could derive the structure of the human heart from string theory in principle, string theory would never tell us that its most important function is to pump blood. The function of biological organs arose as an adaptive consequence of the countless unpredictable constraints that molded them during evolution. In addition the evolution of both structure and function was a mix-and-match process that depended as much on chance encounters as on strict adaptation. All this can never be captured in a reductionist worldview.
Why biology (and chemistry) is not physics - Ashutosh (Ash) Jogalekar, Fieldofscience.com
Subscribe to the newsletter
[x]
Stay in touch with the scientific world!
Know Science And Want To Write?
Apply for a column: writing@science20.com
Donate or Buy SWAG
Please donate so science experts can write
for the public.
At Science 2.0, scientists are the journalists,
with no political bias or editorial control. We
can't do it alone so please make a difference.
We are a nonprofit science journalism
group operating under Section 501(c)(3)
of the Internal Revenue Code that's
educated over 300 million people.
You can help with a tax-deductible
donation today and 100 percent of your
gift will go toward our programs,
no salaries or offices.
- Life On Arsenic? Why Some Science Just Won’t Die - And Why It Matters For Real Discovery
- The Hemp Industry Has A Placebo For Your PFAS Chemophobia
- Conferences Good And Bad, In A Profit-Driven Society
- If You Want To Golf Better, Don't Play With A Republican
- TSCA: Here Is What You Need To Know About EPA Taking A New Look At Formaldehyde
- $0.50 Pantoprazole For Stomach Bleeding In ICU Patients Could Save Families Thousands Of Dollars
- Sending Health Care To Homes Is Better And Cheaper Than Hospital Stays
Interesting insights from outside Science 2.0
Who's
Online?
Online?
© 2025 Science 2.0



Comments