The issue at hand: a student with Asperger's Syndrome feels the teacher withholds recess breaks at a whim; the teacher feels that withholding recess is reinforcing the consequences of the student's actions. From their personal viewpoints, each of them is correct. Clearly, there is bad communication or signaling going on here.
Note I use the shorthand 'Aspie' for 'someone with Asperger's syndrome', itself either a form of high-functioning autism, or a related pervasive developmental disorder (PDD), and the term 'neurotypical' to describe someone who does not have Asperger's.
On Rules Processing
This Aspie Student does understand the general rules in that he can repeat
them, but it's very common with Aspies to have a mismatch between what
an authority figure thinks is a reasonable sequence of events, and what
the Aspie perceives.
One thing to distinguish is 'memory' from 'application'. The Student can
quote back rules, however, the application of those rules is still a
difficult topic of study. To give an extreme example, most of us can
handle the general rule 'do not talk during class' because we understand
the framing and social assumptions with that. But what does that
statement really say?
1) Do not talk during class.
2) Unless the teacher calls on you.
3) Or unless it's group interaction time.
4) And if another student talks and doesn't get punished, that doesn't mean you can.
5) Absolutely never talk during tests.
6) Unless you have a question about the test, then you can talk.
7) Except if your question isn't what the teacher considers relevant, you're in trouble.
8) Also, do talk up if you're being bullied or there is a problem.
9) However, if the teacher doesn't agree with your opinion, you'll be in trouble.
10) Fortunately, if you break any of these
rules, the teacher will remind you "don't talk in class".
Broken out like that, it seems (to a neurotypical) artificially complex. But that's how literal processing works.
best way to think of it is that, to this Student, each classroom is a foreign
country. Scouts or a Sport or Church are likewise foreign countries. Excursions are foreign
trips. Some of the countries are similar and some are different, but
they all have foreign customs that must be memorized and sequenced--
they can't just be assumed.
Until next week,
Tuesdays at The Satellite Diaries and weekly at The Daytime Astronomer (twitter @skyday)
p.s. an apology
Having me discuss how people with autism and Aspergers syndrome think is
a perilous task. Not being of that population, it's akin to me saying
"this is how a foreigner thinks" and thus it fails on two levels.
First, my lay analogy mistakenly assumes the involved population are all
the same, that there's one 'way of thought' they all follow. Second, a
genuine thought model would require specialized training in, say,
psychology or neurolinguistics or something other than 'space science'.
However, I found myself forced to create an analogy while arguing with a
public school system about rules enforcement against a specific student with
Aspergers. And in this, I feel comforted by the fact that, whether my
analogy is strong or weak matters much less than the fact that the
school is so far off the mark that any analogy can only help.
- PHYSICAL SCIENCES
- EARTH SCIENCES
- LIFE SCIENCES
- SOCIAL SCIENCES
Subscribe to the newsletter
Stay in touch with the scientific world!
Know Science And Want To Write?
- Top Secret: On Confidentiality On Scientific Issues, Across The Ring And Across The Bedroom
- The Mystery Of The Red Sea
- Stop Using BMI To Determine Health
- Would New Planet X Clear Its Orbit? - And Any Better Name Than "Planet Nine"?
- The Greenhouse Effect Fallacy
- Intense Work Helped Michelangelo Maintain Use Of Hands Despite Osteoarthritis
- Why Diamonds Are More Of A Scientific Miracle Than You Think
- "This article calls to mind the Diamond Group at the Reading University Physics Department. They..."
- "Greetings Robert. Thanks again for your thoughts on God. I read your two statements and here are..."
- "Hello Vance,yes I know about that model, and about at least two experimental attempts, one with..."
- "No, I am not from the states. It sounds like an astonishing arrangement to have multiple jurisdiction..."
- "Very true. The observation I've made is that in 2001 it was John F. Nash and Alicia DeLarde ..."
- Indonesia’s Many Human Physical Deformities: A Closer Look
- Spinal ‘Column’: Love for Hunchback Dog, Breakthrough for 8-Yr-Old Girl
- BMI is Bologna
- Energy Drinks: The Dose Makes the Poison
- California’s Prop 65: Bad For Public Acceptance Of Science, About To Get Worse
- Wear Red Today! It’s Women’s Heart Health Awareness Day
- Cambridge researcher develops smartphone app to map Swiss-German dialects
- Studies link healthy workforces to positive stock market performance
- Pioneering discovery leads to potential preventive treatment for sudden cardiac death
- Online shopping might not be as green as we thought
- Gene family turns cancer cells into aggressive stem cells that keep growing