Belief In Personal God Improves Response To Depression Treatment
    By News Staff | February 23rd 2010 12:00 AM | 2 comments | Print | E-mail | Track Comments
    Patients diagnosed with clinical depression may respond better to medical treatment as a result of belief in a personal God, say researchers at Rush University Medical Center writing in the Journal of Clinical Psychology.

    136 adults diagnosed with major depression or bipolar depression at inpatient and outpatient psychiatric care facilities in Chicago participated in the study. The patients were surveyed shortly after admission for treatment and eight weeks later, using the Beck Depression Inventory, the Beck Hopelessness Scale, and the Religious Well-Being Scale – all standard instruments in the social sciences for assessing intensity, severity and depth of disease and feelings of hopelessness and spiritual satisfaction.

    Response to medication, defined as a 50-percent reduction in symptoms, can vary in psychiatric patients. Some may not respond at all. But the study found that those with strong beliefs in a personal and concerned God were more likely to experience an improvement. Specifically, participants who scored in the top third of the Religious Well-Being Scale were 75-percent more likely to get better with medical treatment for clinical depression.

    The researchers tested whether the explanation for the improved response was linked instead to the feeling of hope, which is typically a feature of religious belief. But degree of hopefulness, measured by feelings and expectations for the future and degree of motivation, did not predict whether a patient fared better on anti-depressants.

    "In our study, the positive response to medication had little to do with the feeling of hope that typically accompanies spiritual belief," said Patricia Murphy, PhD, a chaplain at Rush and an assistant professor of religion, health and human values at Rush University. "It was tied specifically to the belief that a Supreme Being cared."

    "For people diagnosed with clinical depression, medication certainly plays an important role in reducing symptoms," Murphy said. "But when treating persons diagnosed with depression, clinicians need to be aware of the role of religion in their patients' lives. It is an important resource in planning their care."

    Citation: Patricia E. Murphy, George Fitchett, 'Belief in a concerned god predicts response to treatment for adults with clinical depression', Journal of Clinical Psychology, May 2009, 65(9), 1000 - 1008; doi: 10.1002/jclp.20598


    This is an intriguing theory. It is common for those suffering depression to express a feeling of hopelessness. It is possible that those who believe in a higher being may see more hope in the world than those with no religious belief's. This may also result in a more positive outlook on life, giving them a head start regarding therapy.
    However, I would still like to see a similar study on a larger scale.

    Gerhard Adam
    This is pretty biased, since it fails to take into account many other possible belief systems that might also exert a positive influence on an individual's outlook.  So, it's not surprising when only one type of sample is used that it should surface as the one type that worked.

    Since the there doesn't seem to be an attempt to define or articulate what types of beliefs or philosophies are being compared, this study is little more than self-indulgent nonsense.
    Mundus vult decipi