Obesity isn't always presenting an accurate picture of health. BMI is a nice metric for television shows but in reality, simplistic notions of height, weight and circumference are only a guideline when it comes to predicting health.

A lack of physical activity, a poor diet and hours every day reading Science 2.0 isn't a great idea, but obesity alone is not providing insult into metabolic fitness. Not everyone obese is going to get diabetes, though you'd be hard-pressed to know that if you read the New York Times or watch Dr. Oz.

A study of 181 children with obesity aged eight to 17 years old showed that up to a third could be classified as "metabolically healthy," meaning they're not at risk of developing diabetes, high blood pressure, high cholesterol or other obesity-related diseases. Not yet, anyway.

"It's not all about fat, even for kids who meet the definition of obesity," explained Geoff Ball, senior author and associate professor of pediatrics at the University of Alberta. "Lifestyle behaviors — how physically active they are and what they eat — those things have an effect on their health, independent of fatness."




Prof. Geoff Ball,  University of Alberta. Credit: Richard Siemens/University of Alberta

Ball and his team studied five years' worth of clinical data, tracking the age and body composition of obese children, lifestyle behaviors such as physical activity and diet, along with clinical indicators associated with obesity such as insulin resistance, blood pressure, and fat and glucose levels in the blood.


Fewer calories consumed, less screen time




Though numerous studies have explored whether patients with obesity can be metabolically healthy, few have focused on children. In addition to being more physically active, metabolically healthier children were younger, shorter, lighter and less overweight than their metabolically unhealthy peers. They also spent less time in front of the TV, computer or video game console and ate fewer overall calories, including less fat and fewer servings of meat.

The study included traditional measures of obesity such as body mass index, which factors in an individual's height and weight but doesn't tell the whole story, Ball said.

"Obesity is often described as a complex disease with lots of causes and lots of consequences. Not everyone has the same consequences," he said. "Someone with Type 2 diabetes could have less body fat than somebody who has quite a bit more body fat and doesn't have Type 2 diabetes. There is considerable variability between individuals."

Ball said the findings should help physicians and other health professionals understand the complexity of obesity for treating patients and prioritizing referral to specialized weight-management care. Roughly two million young, obese Canadians meet eligibility criteria for such treatment—far more than the two dozen or so clinics across the country can accommodate, he added.

For Edmonton-area patients, having access to the comprehensive management approach at the Stollery's Pediatric Centre for Weight and Health means families receive the most appropriate intervention based on their health status and individual needs. The multidisciplinary team, including a physician, registered nurse, registered dietitian, exercise specialist, and psychologist provide healthy lifestyle messages to children and families that assist them on their journey towards greater health and well-being.


National study recruiting 1,600 children




Ball's team is now focusing on a larger national study, including what happens to children with obesity—metabolically healthy or otherwise—over time and whether risks of obesity-related illness eventually catch up. That work will see the researchers recruit 1,600 Canadian children currently receiving weight-management care and follow them over several years through lifestyle interventions that focus on improving health and well-being.

Ball said these kids and their families are accessing health services that hopefully have a positive effect on their health and well-being. Health professionals need to know whether children who are metabolically healthy stay that way over time as they mature and if there are conditions in the health system and beyond that help make it possible.

"Since most children with obesity find it challenging to lose and maintain weight loss over time, improving metabolic health by being physically active and eating healthfully is an important result in and of itself."

Published in the journal Diabetes Care. Source: University of Alberta