Biologists studying a population of lizards on the Bahamas say that competition among the brown anole lizard (Anolis sagrei) is more important than predation by birds and snakes when it comes to survival of the fittest lizard.

The Dartmouth team's results, published in Nature, may also aid efforts to teach the public about evolution.

For the study, researchers covered multiple small islands in the Bahamas with bird-proof netting to keep predatory birds at bay. Other islands were left open to bird predators, and on still other islands, the researchers added predatory snakes to expose the lizards to both bird and snake predators. Next, they tracked the lizards over the summer to record which lizards lived and which died on the different islands.

"We found repeated evidence that death by predators occurred at random with respect to traits like body size and running ability" said Robert Cox, a post-doctoral researcher at Dartmouth. "But we also found that increasing the density of lizards on an island consistently created strong natural selection favoring larger size and better running ability."

The authors explain that in high-density populations, the intensity of competition for food, space, and other resources is likely to increase. In turn, this increased competition favors the biggest, toughest lizards on the island.

While competition will not always be more important than predation in other species or in different environments, the researchers acknowledge, they emphasize that their study has broad social implications because it demonstrates the ability to conduct evolutionary experiments in natural animal populations.

"Many people are skeptical of evolutionary biology because they perceive it as a purely historical science that can't be tested experimentally. Here, we're providing a real experimental test of natural selection as it happens in the wild. That's an exciting way for us to advance the public's perception of evolution" Ryan Calsbeek, an assistant professor of biology at Dartmouth College.

Citation: Ryan Calsbeek, Robert M. Cox, 'Experimentally assessing the relative importance of predation and competition as agents of selection', Nature, 2010; doi: 10.1038/nature09020