The media absolutely gushed over the possibility that smoking leads to brain damage, highlighted in a 'study' Monday. They were so happy to not have to write about another miracle vegetable or marshmallow cannons and call it 'science' they didn't bother to really read the data, so the news coverage of the study was misleading and highlighted why we need better science journalism.
They didn't bother to note that the study was observational, they only examined "... the association between smoking history and cognitive decline in the transition from midlife to old age." Participants reported their own smoking habits spanning a period of 25 years. Self-reported data like this can be problematic because there are no controls in place. People can easily misreport how much they smoke in either direction. Additionally, as the authors themselves admit, the data "... cannot be assumed to be representative of the general population," because the participants were white-collar civil servants.
Smoking Causes Brain Damage? Why We Need Better Science Journalism by Cameron English, Policy Mic
- PHYSICAL SCIENCES
- EARTH SCIENCES
- LIFE SCIENCES
- SOCIAL SCIENCES
Subscribe to the newsletter
Stay in touch with the scientific world!
Know Science And Want To Write?
- Poisons Chemists Hate, But You Just Ate
- CERN And LIP Openings For Graduate Students In Physics - Good $$$
- Supersymmetry Is About To Be Discovered, Kane Says
- End Racist Sexism At US Universities Now
- Our Ethical Responsibilities To Baby Terraformed Worlds - Like Parents
- Single Top Production At The LHC
- IQ: Why 1904 Testing Shouldn't Be Used Today
- "hi there mr walker ive only just heard about nibiru today and ive seen videos after videos I must..."
- "I don't know, seems the LASCO one has got stuck at 8.18 this morning. Try the video for the previous..."
- "how come the soho cam takes so long to change because ive just looked at it and the time still..."
- "so I can have a fear free Christmas and enjoy it with my kids and not keep living in fear of this..."
- "There is nothing at all to be scared of. Can you not see for yourself how silly it all is?..."
- Men who forgo aggressive treatment for prostate cancer don't receive appropriate monitoring
- Watching eyes prevent littering
- Physicians and burnout: It's getting worse
- Posttraumatic stress disorder reveals an imbalance between signalling systems in the brain
- Trap-jaw ants exhibit previously unseen jumping behavior