Banner
    Burning Tumors With Magnetism
    By ... ... | July 3rd 2011 07:11 AM | 7 comments | Print | E-mail | Track Comments
    About ...

    ... Now at a new blog, called The Beast, the Bard and the Bot....

    View ...'s Profile

    Cancer cells, like normal cells, begin to perish as soon as the temperature hits 43°C. So, the obvious challenge is to find out how cancer cells can be heated up without affecting the normal, healthy cells. One idea to deal with it, is known as magnetic hyperthermia. This involves injecting magnetic nanoparticles into the targeted tumors (For another nanoparticle approach to cancer, click here). Subsequently, the patient is put into a magnetic field that reverses direction several thousands of times each second. This excites the nanoparticles, heating them. Since the magnetic particles are only found in the tumors, the healthy tissue is exempt from the damaging heat.

    However, there is a problem with this approach. Conventional nanoparticles interact only modestly with the magnetic field. To counteract this, larger doses are required. While the used nanoparticles usually aren’t really toxic, large doses can activate the immune system, which might result in allergic reactions.

    Now, a new nanoparticle has been developed that gets hotter than conventional nanoparticles. These nanoparticles have two layers, a core of one magnetic material, and a surface layer of another one (see figure 1). This appears to make these particles interact more strongly with the magnetic field, releasing up to 10 times more heat, meaning that only 10% of the usual dose of nanoparticles is required to achieve the same amount of heat as in previously used particles.

    Figure 1: The new nanoparticles. (Source: Lee et al., 2011)

    The research team, at Yonsei University in Seoul, tested their new technique on mice. After injecting their newly designed nanoparticles, they put the mice inside a coil of wire (see figure 2) and alternated the current, creating a quickly alternating magnetic field. Ten minutes later, the mice were removed, and their tumors were monitored for a four week period. All traces of cancer disappeared in the mice, and no apparent side-effects were noticed. This discovery might spur new research into the development of magnetic nanoparticle therapies for cancer, which has been struggling due to the low interaction with a magnetic field by conventional particles.

    Figure 2: Mouse in coil of wire. (Source: Lee et al., 2011)

    Reference

    Lee, J.-H.; Jang, J.-T.; Choi, J.-S.; Moon, S.H.; Noh, S.-H.; Kim, J.-W.; Kim, J.-G.; Kim,I.-S.; Park, K.I. and Cheon, J. (2011). Exchange-coupled magnetic nanoparticles for efficient heat induction. Nature Nanotechnology. doi:10.1038/nnano.2011.95.

    Comments

    Bonny Bonobo alias Brat
    I wonder if the mice end up being magnetised with a north and south pole? This could have some interesting repercussions.
    Make love not war
    rholley
    Helen,

    You are starting to make me think physics.  When I did magnetism in my teens, I remember learning about degaussing, a technique to minimize the magnetic field of ships’s hulls so that they would not set off magnetic mines.  Maybe they turn the alternating field down slowly to achieve a similar effect.

    Then again, strongly magnetic materials are far from being ‘much of a muchness’.  For instance, mu-metal responds rapidly and strongly to magnetic fields, while iron, though more sluggish, has a high hysteresis so a lot more heat should be generated.  I wonder how these nanoparticles would respond?

    This, from the Wikipedia article on hysteresis, shows how the magnetization curve as one poles the materials one way is different from that when one reverses the polarity.

    My understanding is that a fat hysteresis loop would indicate lots of heating, but would also tend to permanently magnetize the mice.

    P.S. regarding mu-metal,
    Mu-metal was developed by scientists named Smith and Garnett and patented in 1923 for inductive loading of submarine telegraph cables by The Telegraph Construction and Maintenance Co. Ltd. (now Telcon Metals Ltd.), a British firm which built the Atlantic undersea telegraph cables.
    I visited that company on a school trip, in the early 60s.  Nice to know they’re still around.
    Robert H. Olley Quondam Physics Department University of Reading England
    Bonny Bonobo alias Brat
    Robert, you are always such a wonderful mine of information. This is all very interesting but unfortunately, because of my nature, I can't help wondering about the effects of these experiments on the mice. Firstly, they might be very confused about why the mouse wheel failed to provide them with any obvious means of excercise and amusement, just a few hot spots, secondly they might wonder why they now have a strong attraction to anything metallic, thirdly they might also wonder why they can no longer sniff their own tails.
    Make love not war
    rholley
    I'm also wondering how it affects the mice.  All that harrumphing about magnetism is really listing the “known unknowns”.

    I’ve posted a request for the paper.
    Robert H. Olley Quondam Physics Department University of Reading England
    rholley
    Helen,

    My posted request has been answered, and it appears that the particles are superparamagnetic.  The paper itself says:
    These nanoparticles demonstrate superparamagnetism at room temperature, an important property for biomedical applications. In contrast to ferromagnetic nanoparticles, superparamagnetism can prevent nanoparticle aggregation or cluster formation, because the spin relaxes quickly and demagnetizes at room temperature.
    I understand from this that the mice do not remain permanently magnetized.
    Robert H. Olley Quondam Physics Department University of Reading England
    Bonny Bonobo alias Brat

    Thanks very much for the feedback Robert, especially the link to Wikipedia's superparamagnetic article which has a link to a very interesting superparamagnetic clustering program at a website called the Virtual ComputationalChemistry laboratory which states that :-

    The overall objective of this project is to develop multi-platform software allowing the computational chemist to perform acomprehensive series of molecular properties calculations and data analysis on the Internet. The software will be based on three-tier architecture that is becoming widespread to provide client-server services over the world.

    What's amazing is that they seem to be providing free internet access to the following on-line software :-

    • ALOGPS 2.1* is the most accurate program to predict lipophilicity and aqueous solubility of molecules
    • ASNN* calculates highly predictive non-linear neural network models
    • E-BABEL is molecular structure information interchange hub
    • PNN produces clearly interpretable analytical non-linear models
    • PCLIENT generates more than 3000 descriptors
    • E-DRAGON calculates DRAGON molecular indices
    • PLS implements original two-step descriptors selection procedure
    • UFS produces a reduced data set that contains no redundancy and a minimal amount of multicollinearity
    Its quite amazing what is now available on the internet for people like me to just play around with.
    Make love not war
    G.D.W.
    Thanks for the information, Robert.