Banner
By News Staff | August 24th 2009 08:20 PM | 7 comments | Print | E-mail | Track Comments
Is music more than the sum of its parts?   We're going to find out if the right words and musical notes can lead to Frankenstein-ish success.

A University of Hertfordshire academic says he has 'compiled' the ideal David Bowie song, which according to psychological theory should lead to success in the charts and maybe improved health for the singer (we'll get back to that).

Dr Nick Troop, Principal Lecturer in Health Psychology at Hertfordshire but also a musician and, unsurprisingly, an avid David Bowie fan, says he analyzed the singer’s 26 albums and 266 songs for links between language used and success in the charts and then wrote what he considered to be the ideal song, which he will release on YouTube Tuesday.  So get ready - that is, if you can actually find anything on YouTube.

Troop’s interest in Bowie started as a hobby but he says he was also motivated by studies which he and others have carried out that prove that writing about trauma and life goals have long-term benefits to health.

He used the Linguistic Inquiry and Word Count (LIWC), a program developed by James Pennebaker,  psychologist at the University of Texas, to investigate psychological constructs represented in text. It claims to be a quantitative analysis of psychological processes reflected in the words Bowie uses rather than a qualitative interpretation of the meaning of his songs.

“I looked at the link between the language used and how long Bowie’s albums had spent in the charts,” said Troop. “I found that the songs with positive emotion and social processes were more successful than the songs that talked about mortality.”

Using this approach, Troop says he then wrote the ideal Bowie song and here it is though, like we said, you have to wait until tomorrow to get the video (but we'll include it [edit - and did!):




*******

Team, Meet Girls; Girls, Meet Team (© Nick Troop, 2009)

Buddy loves good loving : Calm and proud while peace wins

Warmth and conversation : Heaven’s energy and an elegant charm

                Truth wins – an adult love to win awards

Sweet faith : Secure in the affection of a better boy

Feeling admiration : A cheerful kiss, kiss the phone

                Truth wins – an adult love to win awards

                Team, meet girls; girls, meet team

They met and were loving : Perfectly amazed, comfort and cared for

A loyal companion : Share, relax, creating humans XXX

                Dear charm, playing nice give paradise smiles

                Truth wins – an adult love to win awards

                Team, meet girls; girls, meet team

                Team, meet girls; girls, meet team

Special persons with casual ease enjoy the band

Lucky and rich, a special guest hero

                Team, meet girls; girls, meet team

                Team, meet girls; girls, meet team

                Girls, meet team; team, meet girls

*******

During the next academic year, Dr Troop plans to use some of the theories applied in this research to work with his psychology students to look at how different kinds of word usage can affect mood and other health outcomes, with a particular emphasis on song writing.



Comments

Hank
This is the funniest thing I read today.

faisalamlani
wow, that wasn't half bad. this dude's love for bowie is genuine, huh

Hank
Indeed, though I remain skeptical that one can analyze the paintings of DaVinci and make a composite that is better than the Mona Lisa.  Bowie is no DaVinci, of course, he's a pop musician and not one I ever much liked, but I still prefer to regard music as more than a careful synthesis of previous chord progressions and words.

faisalamlani
i agree. a famous mathematician from the early 20th century (I believe his name to be "Birkhoff") took a long sabbatical away from his work to research and publish a book called "Aesthetic Measure", where he tried just that. his goal was to be able to apply a sense of mathematical value to the aesthetics of music, poetry, painting, etc. he failed miserably, of course, but i believe the spirit of his book was to ultimately derive a mathematical composite (e.g. a poem or melody) that had a prescribed aesthetic value.

the famous french physicist / mathematician Fourier also tried to use his "Fourier series" to construct universally pleasing harmonies. he wasn't the only from the french enlightenment to try it -- their ideas were admirable but i think they forgot to account for an emotional / human element to a harmony or melody, one that is very hard to quantify.

Hank
Right, it's still an interesting analysis.  Dick Clark, I believe, once made a bet he could take any kid with some talent and make him a star ... and came up with Dion (1) to prove it.  He wasn't wrong.   At least in western harmony/notation, what pleases people doesn't change much, other than by era.   C Am F G was big in the 40s and 50s, for example, while C,F and G was rock and roll but they were still western.


Troop's song certainly sounds like a pop song and the words go together well for being basically meaningless.

(1) I couldn't find a verification for that so it may have been someone else discovering Dion, or Dick Clark discovering someone else, or a figment of my youth.

Um. The lyrics sound more like the Ultimate Syd Barrett Song!

I am sorry to say that after all of this analysis (which is very interesting)...I'm just not that into the song, regardless of who "wrote" it.

I think that's the real test of the thing: who wants to hear it on the radio all the time? Anyone? Do you love it, or are you just impressed that someone came up with this idea?

Add a comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <sup> <sub> <a> <em> <strong> <center> <cite><TH><ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <br> <p> <blockquote> <strike> <object> <param> <embed> <del> <pre> <b> <i> <table> <tbody> <div> <tr> <td> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <hr> <iframe>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
CAPTCHA
If you register, you will never be bothered to prove you are human again. And you get a real editor toolbar to use instead of this HTML thing that wards off spam bots.