Banner
    Engineering Absolved - London Millenium Bridge 'Wobble' Happened Because People Walk Wrong
    By News Staff | December 16th 2008 02:00 AM | 2 comments | Print | E-mail | Track Comments
    On its opening day, the London Millennium Bridge experienced unexpected swaying due to the large number of people crossing it. A new study finally explains the Millennium Bridge 'wobble' by concluding that humans did not walk the way engineers would have preferred.

    It has generally been thought the Millennium Bridge 'wobble' was due to pedestrians synchronizing their footsteps with the bridge motion. However, this is not supported by measurements of the phenomenon on other bridges.

    Instead, it was the behavior of pedestrians and it has also been identified on several other bridges, including Bristol's famous Clifton Suspension Bridge. The phenomenon is not related to the structural form of the bridge, but rather the behavior of the people walking on it. The paper by civil engineers at the University of Bristol, published in the Royal Society journal Proceedings of the Royal Society A, examines the basic way humans maintain balance.


    The most famous wobble in America: The Tacoma Narrows Bridge Collapse of 1940, though that one was resonance and not pesky people who chose not to walk the way engineers had designed the London Millenum Bridge to withstand.

    Balance is achieved by changing the position of foot placement for each step, based only on the final displacement and speed of the centre of mass from the previous step.  The same balance strategy as for normal walking on a stationary surface was applied to walking on a laterally swaying bridge.

    Without altering their pacing frequency, averaged over a large number of cycles, the pedestrian can effectively act as a negative damper to the bridge motion, which may be at different frequency. Hence the pedestrian can inadvertently feed energy into bridge oscillations.

    Dr John Macdonald, Senior Lecturer in Civil Engineering, said: "It is clear that the motion of the bridge affects the force from the pedestrian, rather than the pedestrian simply applying an external force."

    The researchers found, to their surprise, that pedestrians walking randomly, keeping balance as normal can cause large bridge sway. This finally seems to explain the initiation of the Millennium Bridge 'wobble' and gives new insight for designing bridges to avoid vibration problems.

    Comments

    jtwitten
    Any comment from Strogatz on this?  The spontaneous synchronization of pedestrians walking was a major part of the presentation I saw him give.
    Hank
    I wouldn't know how to reach him but here is a video of him posted this month: