Why Do So Many Dogs Commit Suicide Off This Bridge In Scotland?
    By Hank Campbell | December 20th 2012 06:09 PM | 7 comments | Print | E-mail | Track Comments
    Over the past 50 years, about 50 dogs have jumped to their deaths from the exact same spot on the 100-year-old Overtoun Bridge in Milton, near Dumbarton, Scotland.

    What gives? 

     Almost all the incidents have taken place on clear, sunny days and the dogs always being long-nosed breeds – collies, retrievers and labs.  The canine suicide spot is located between the last two parapets on the right-hand side of the bridge.

    Celtic mythology has an explanation but it won't be satisfying to a science audience - that Overtoun is a ‘thin place’, an area where heaven and Earth are at their closest. Since dogs are more sensitive than humans, they are believed to pick up the vibrations more easily, leading to their strange behavior.

    So if you are in Milton and off for a leisurely stroll over the bridge with your best friend, stay on the left - and keep him on a leash.

    Comments

    Hank
    In the movie "1408", a few dozen people had died in one hotel room over a hundred years or whatever.  Clearly a hotel with a 90% occupancy rate had 30,000 people or so stay there without incident. So it goes with 50 dogs on a bridge in 50 years. No idea how many dogs walk over that bridge every day. Maybe they are depressed about living in Scotland.
    Want more no-nonsense, independent science? Buy Science Left Behind
    Gerhard Adam
    Apparently from the description, there's no reason to believe that the dogs are aware that the ground isn't flat on the opposite side of the wall, since they can't see over it.  Therefore, they also can't know that it would lead to them falling.

    It appears there are also small animals around, and specifically a point was made about mink being around, which may well cause a dog to dash off and attempt a pursuit.  Jumping the wall, of course, doesn't lead to the results the dog anticipated.

    Most importantly, it doesn't seem that the number of 50 dogs can be supported, regardless of how many years the phenomenon is claimed to have existed.
    Hank
    So that Heaven and Earth meeting on the bridge stuff is not real. Next you'll be debunking the rest of Celtic mythology.
    Want more no-nonsense, independent science? Buy Science Left Behind
    Gerhard Adam
    By Donar, everyone knows that the Celtic myths weren't real.  Next you'll be claiming that Wotan, All-Father, is a myth too.

    [Note:  Donar = Germanic; Thor = Norse.  Wotan = Germanic; Odin = Norse]
    Hank
    Your Teutonic bias betrays you.  There wasn't a UK Celtic deity anywhere in there. No Dagda?  No Morrigan?  Robert Olley is going to be hurling a Gaesum if something Welsh isn't thrown in there.

    You can duck behind my copy of "The Mabinogion".
    Want more no-nonsense, independent science? Buy Science Left Behind
    Gerhard Adam
    Bias?  That suggests that there might be alleged viable alternatives.