Google is doing some spring cleaning and booted seven projects that were outside what they regard as their core business, the most high-profile of which was its attempt to make solar energy cheaper than coal.
It was a grand effort and Google is a smart company but solar is simply too inefficient in its current state. The Department of Energy has a huge chunk of its $36 billion 'venture capital' efforts riding on current solar energy companies but they did it in a rush - a plan that had been in effect since 2005 but with no companies passing muster suddenly was handing money to every company from 2009-2011, so in a world of crystalline solar panels they have been endorsing expensive copper indium gallium selenide (CIGS) technology and the result is political theater and a lot of people asking why the Department of Energy is claiming it knows more than venture capitalists about investing and then rationalizing bad investments weren't wrong because venture capitalists were also in those companies. Unless we get rid of the EPA and force people to work for $5,000 a year, solar technology is going to be cheaper in China so let them manufacture them and incur the subsidies to make them cheap enough to buy here.
The rationale behind subsidizing domestic manufacturing only makes sense to people with no business experience, which unfortunately includes Energy Secretary and Nobel Laureate Steven Chu. He is trying to imply we are in a race with China to build as many solar panels as possible but it's hard to figure out why he believes that; it's like saying we are in a race with China to build 2002-era PCs. We're not putting in an infrastructure for the future and we're not getting better at building future PCs by building and relying on old ones and so it goes with solar. Chu was hired for his research credibility, not his business acumen, so forcing him into a role he is ill-suited for is bad for everyone.
Google recognizes the weaknesses in current solar technology and its "Green Energy Czar", Bill Weihl, left earlier this month.
There is a lesson in here; alternative energy is clearly the future but subsidizing companies now will not lead to a better future, it will make current companies reliant on legacy technology and government funding. Even the staunchest progressives inside DoE recognize that oil companies are resistant to green energy because current energy is how they make their money, yet they seem to think creating new companies reliant on government funding will be different. It's ethanol all over again; only now that he is out of politics does Al Gore concede his support for ethanol was political and not science-based, the opposite of what he claimed at the time.
We'd be better off if the Obama administration changed course and abandoned the corporate welfare plan and instead focused exclusively on funding research that could have a legitimate breakthrough - yet insiders at DoE, who ordinarily would be fans of research, seem fixated on Keynesian economics for green tech. Alternative energy is the future and some sharp investigator can find it but the way to find that person is to fund as much basic research as possible and not fund private companies for $500,000 per employee.
Google quits plans to make cheap renewable energy - By Alexei Oreskovic, Reuters
- PHYSICAL SCIENCES
- EARTH SCIENCES
- LIFE SCIENCES
- SOCIAL SCIENCES
Subscribe to the newsletter
Stay in touch with the scientific world!
Know Science And Want To Write?
- Wait, Let's Not Be In Such A Rush To Go Multiplanetary Or Interstellar - A Comment On Elon Musk's Vision
- Petition To Youtube To Halt Ads On Doomsday Videos - They Make The Vulnerable Suicidal
- Paleo: In A Clinical Trial, Bread Made With Ancient Grains Could Benefit Heart Health
- Hubble Spots Europa Geysers Again - How They Did It - And What Next? Flyby? Lander?
- Chatelperronian Hominins: Disputed Neanderthal Region Confirmed In France
- No Go Area! What? What is that?
- Why Psychology Lost Its Soul - Science Replaced It
- "Oh, sorry to hear that, I hear this so often. Basically it's like propoganda I think. Propoganda..."
- "Hi mr walker... lately i havent been able to eat or drink.. and if i do sleep its during the whole..."
- "Right, California did, but prior to that there were schools in Marin with only 25% vaccination..."
- "I don't just mean Trump - I mean Paul, Fiorina, Christie, and to the medical community's horror..."
- "I like how Farid's lifestyle changed so that he could identify in a way that he wanted people to..."
- Is Parenting Kids of Human and Canine Persuasion the Same? Yes!
- Diabetes: MiniMed 670G Hybrid Closed-Loop Insulin System Is A Waypoint To An Artificial Pancreas
- Celebrate Oktoberfest with Beer Chemistry
- Littlest Consumers Doing Well, Nutrition-wise
- Herpes Vaccine Update: Exciting News, But Don't Throw Away Condoms Just Yet
- Ben & Jerry’s Asks Us to Take Big Lick of Fear & Hype
- Antipsychotic medications linked to increased risk of pneumonia in persons with Alzheimer's disease
- Multiple sclerosis misdiagnosis shows need for improved education of clinicians
- Brown adipose tissue can secrete factors that activate fat and carbohydrate metabolism
- Therapeutic Gene Delivery for Inherited Retinal Degeneration in Children
- Molecular atlas of the pancreas