Banner
    "True Blood" Is Killing Your Marriage
    By Hank Campbell | September 18th 2012 03:54 PM | 4 comments | Print | E-mail | Track Comments
    If you were to ask me yesterday what did the most harm to romantic relationships, I would have said 'romantic comedies' followed by 'advice from women'.

    Why?  Let's face it, you would get arrested for romantic comedy behavior in real life.  No one wants their wedding broken up and guys running around the city on horseback are just an accident waiting to happen.  And advice from women is also dead on arrival - women give men advice like 'take a chance and talk to her' without telling men that the only people that women really want taking a chance look like George Clooney and have a Tuscan villa to match.  In all other instances, wait for a sign and then proceed with caution.  And that's downright generous compared to the advice women give to other women, like 'your new, short haircut looks really cute'.  Secretly, they are cheering because that woman just removed herself from the dating pool.

    Well, I am wrong in thinking those are the Big Two.  A study in Mass Communication and Society says its television doing the most damage.  They may have a point.  If guys think dating is a plot from "Two And A Half Men" well, Charlie Sheen is not all that adorable in real life.   And don't even get me started on how "True Blood" can whack out the expectations of women. Sorry, we can't be mopey and broken after 200 years.

    In the paper, 390 married couples participated in a survey which had questions about their satisfaction level with their romantic relationship, expectations, etc. and then how authentic they thought television portrayals of romantic relationships were and how often they watched shows that had romance.

    No surprise that the more a person 'believed' in  television romantic portrayals, the greater their unhappiness with real life.

    “In this study I found that people who believe the unrealistic portrayals on TV are actually less committed to their spouses and think their alternatives to their spouse are relatively attractive,” Dr. Jeremy Osborn said in a released statement, and reading a press release is really all of the analysis I did for this blog post. “We live in a society that perpetually immerses itself in media images from both TV and the web, but most people have no sense of the ways those images are impacting them. The rate of marriage failure in the U. S. is not dropping, and it is important for people to have a sense of what factors are leading to the failure of so many relationships.”

    The more obvious solution is to spend less time watching television and more time going for her neck. That is one thing "True Blood" gets right.  Just avoid puncturing the skin.  There's romantic and then there is creepy.

    Citation: Jeremy L. Osborn, 'When TV and Marriage Meet: A Social Exchange Analysis of the Impact of Television Viewing on Marital Satisfaction and Commitment', Mass Communication and Society Sept. 2012, pages 739-757, DOI:10.1080/15205436.2011.618900

    Comments

    UvaE
    No surprise that the more a person 'believed' in  television romantic portrayals, the greater their unhappiness with real life. 
    No problem. I'll get my wife to watch my collection of Flintstones DVDs, and in contrast I will look like Clooney, and our home will seem like a Tuscan villa.
    rholley
    In one of the Fables for Our Time by James Thurber, a wife drove her husband mad by acting out the song “Tea for Two”.  The moral at the end was:

    If life went along like a popular song,
    Every man’s marriage would surely go wrong.

    Robert H. Olley Quondam Physics Department University of Reading England
    UvaE
    I love Thurber's Fables for Our Time. In college I was annoying some people at the library by laughing out loud while reading the book. You've also brought to mind, an excellent short story by Thurber: "The Secret Life of Walter Mitty."
    Here's another one of the Thurber fables that's related to marital conflicts:
    The Shrike and the Chipmunks
    by James Thurber
    Once upon a time there were two chipmunks, a male and a female. The male chipmunk thought that arranging nuts in artistic patters was more fun that just piling them up to see how many you could pile up. The female was all for piling up as many as you could. She told her husband that if he gave up making designs with the nuts there would be room in their large cave for a great many more and he would soon become the wealthiest chipmunk in the woods. But he would not let her interfere with his designs, so she flew into a rage and left him.. “The shrike will get you,” she said, “because you are helpless and cannot look after yourself.” To be sure, the female chipmunk had not been gone three nights before the male had to dress for a banquet and could not find his studs or shirt or suspenders. So he couldn’t go to the banquet, but that was just as well, because all the chipmunks who did go were attached and killed by a weasel.
    The next day the shrike began hanging around outside the chipmunk’s cave, waiting to catch him. The shrike couldn’t get in because the doorway was clogged up with soiled laundry and dirty dishes. “He will come out for a walk after breakfast and I will get him then,” thought the shrike. But the chipmunk slept all day and did not get up and have breakfast until after dark. Then he came out for a breath of fresh air before beginning work on a new design. The shrike swooped down to snatch the chipmunk, but could not see very well on account of the dark, so he batted his head against an alder branch and was killed.
    A few days later the female chipmunk returned and saw the awful mess the house was in. She went to the bed and shook her husband. “What would you do without me?” she demanded. “Just go on living, I guess,” he said. “You wouldn’t last five days,” she told him. She swept the house and did the dishes and sent out the laundry, and then she made the chipmunk get up and wash and dress. “You can’t be healthy if you lie in bed all day and never get any exercise,” she told him. So she took him for a walk in the bright sunlight and they were both caught and killed by the shrike’s brother, a shrike named Stoop.

    Moral: Early to rise and early to bed makes a man healthy and wealthy and dead.
    " And don't even get me started on how "True Blood" can whack out the expectations of women. Sorry, we can't be mopey and broken after 200 years."

    It would be more accurate to say 'Sorry, we can't all be Viking Gods'. Mopey and Broken are ubiquitous in the dating pool.