OpenStreetMap, an alternative to Google map data, has had a lot of success but can't agree on what direction to go next, say those in the know. An odd problem for people who make maps, right?
But at least they are having fun trying.
When I was young, the only sort-of controversy in maps was 'fairness' to third world countries. We didn't say 'developing nations' back then, we said 'third world', just like people who were trying to foment dissent in a country were called 'fifth columnists' but now we call them 'humanities professors'.
Why did maps matter then? The same reason they do now. Humans are built to make graphical representations because 'go right' is too subjective - and they are fun. When I was young I made topographical maps of my D&D world. And where we hunted. Yet the topic of maps came up in a more serious fashion when I was a lad because some people - wait for it, wait for it - believed that regular maps 'fostered European imperialist attitudes for centuries' and created ethnic bias.
Okay, I didn't make that sentence up, though I wish I had. It was in an episode of "The West Wing" clipped by Carl Franzen at TalkingPointsMemo:
Yes, a position among the left so outrageous that West Wing writers made fun of it:
"Are you telling us Germany isn't where we think it is?"
"Nothing is where you think it is."
What do maps have to do with social equality, you ask? So did they. Size matters, they say, so artificially making Europe bigger leads to bias against developing nations that are graphically shown as being smaller.
Size matters. Maps matter. If you want to know why a lot of Arab kids hate Israel, it isn't because of a border dispute from 1968, it is because Israel does not show up on maps in Arab schools and never has.
Scientists don't really have this scale issue. If I talk to a materials scientist and use a graphical Von Mises diagram, or if you show a modeler a model, they get that things are often not scaled to reality, they are scaled so you can see what is going on that is important. But maps are another animal entirely and, as Franzen notes, open source mapping has its own ideas about what matters. They are not working for Google, so they have their own beliefs and those have to be factored in or you lose the people doing this for fun.
Well, it is just accuracy that should matter, right? No, not once you get success. Some mappers are concerned that the trend in Mappy Hours - where people get together and drink and, well, map, is exclusionary for people who do not drink. And others complain the mappers are not diverse enough. Wikipedia feels their pain; they argue it is not their fault only white guys write articles, just like academics say it is not their fault that about the same number of conservatives exist in science academia as there are black women writing on Wikipedia. Mapping seems to be an English-speaking,white-guy thing too, but maybe that is because mostly middle class white guys like to do it. Or maybe not, maybe other countries or even genders are blocked out by the mapper culture.
Sex matters in mapping? Not so much, I am sure cartographers wish they knew more girls, but it gave me a chance to use Franzen's 'sex club' term about modern cartography, and sex and cartography aren't used in sentences together all that often, so we should take those chances when we can get them.
Read parts 1 and 2 first, it got me interested in something I didn't even know people still did today.
The New Cartographers: ‘Mappy Hour,’ Sex Clubs And Diversity by Carl Franzen at Talking Points Memo.
- PHYSICAL SCIENCES
- EARTH SCIENCES
- LIFE SCIENCES
- SOCIAL SCIENCES
Subscribe to the newsletter
Stay in touch with the scientific world!
Know Science And Want To Write?
- NO End Of World Today! AWFUL "Silly Season" Story
- Why An Extra Planet Can't Be Hidden Behind The Sun Or Above The South Pole
- Why Has Organic Farming Flatlined?
- My Applied National Security Paper. Being President Isn't For Idiots.
- The Daily Physics Problem - 5
- Hugh Hefner's Wife Was Not Poisoned By Breast Implants
- SYRINA: A Trojan Horse For Endocrine Disrupting Chemicals?
- "People say Paul Cox says Nibiru is real was he joking..."
- "When it comes to nuke, give me corrupt over insane...."
- "Ian, okay that's about the magnetic pole shift. I haven't actually seen this announcement by NASA..."
- "Apparently mr walker nasa has said that there is a pole shift happening and it will quickly speed..."
- "The same goes for Greenpeace's opposition to nuclear power. It is so easy to scare people about..."
- Tracking how HIV disrupts immune system informs vaccine development
- Green monkeys acquired Staphylococcus aureus from humans
- Researchers find molecular switch that triggers bacterial pathogenicity
- Scientists identify immunological profiles of people who make powerful HIV antibodies
- Breastfeeding associated with better brain development and neurocognitive outcomes