Banner
    Arctic Ice 2011 - Sail, Steam And Satellites
    By Patrick Lockerby | March 1st 2011 09:18 AM | 7 comments | Print | E-mail | Track Comments
    About Patrick

    Retired engineer, 60+ years young. Computer builder and programmer. Linguist specialising in language acquisition and computational linguistics....

    View Patrick's Profile
    Arctic Ice 2011 - Sail, Steam and Satellites

    The NSIDC will shortly be publishing its report for March 2011.  I expect the report to conclude that Arctic sea ice extent for February 2011 was the 'lowest in the satellite record'.  That would mean the 'lowest ever recorded in human history', since we have abundant data on historic ice extent.

    There is a false argument doing the rounds of the blogs: words to the effect that we have no accurate knowledge of ice extent before the age of satellites.  This is, of course, nonsense on stilts in clown boots with a squirting flower - the latter being filled with complete and utter bilge with an admixture of absolute hogwash.

    A child finds it hard to understand how you can map ice extent without satellites, aircraft or at least balloons.

    To accept such a child's-eye view of climate science is to reject the evidence of every fisherman, whaler, sealer, hunter, explorer, missionary, sea captain, geologist, cartographer or ordinary traveler who ever kept a journal; to reject the many thousands of scientific papers written by experts in their subjects even before the steam engine was invented; to reject the findings of modern science which lend further credence to these older eye-witness accounts and scientific studies.

    From the wealth of information available from old written records and proxy measurements it is possible to reconstruct the arctic climate and the extent of sea and land ice going back beyond the first human footprint to be planted on our planet.

    If we had satellites in 1900, our picture of the Arctic in August 1900 would be something like this:


    The Arctic in August 1900 - an approximate reconstruction.

    In fact, the ice as shown in this image is far too little in extent for 1900.  The ice at that time would have covered the entire coasts of Greenland and Iceland.


    The Great Ice Barrier

    Greenland was once unreachable by sea along most of its coasts.  From the Lincoln Sea around Greenland's east coast and up the west coast was the Great Ice Barrier, a vast field of ice sheets and floes through which no ship could pass.

    For much of human history the most skilled explorers of the Arctic were the Inuit.  Even the Inuit, highly skilled in Arctic travel, barely explored or settled the east coast of Greenland.
    The east coast of Greenland was unknown territory for the white man before the 1900 century. Only occasionally it was visited in the 1900 century.
    Ammassalik was discovered by the dane Gustav Holm on a mapping expedition when 4 inuit Umiaqs rounded the southern tip and went northwards along the east coast of Greenland in 1884. Ammassalik was then the biggest community of East Greenland with some over four hundred inhabitants. They were extremely surprised to see foreign "Umiaqs" arriving in the bay.


    ...

    The main reason for that so few people ever have visited this land (east coast) is that 90% of the pack ice in the north pole basin have its outlet to the open sea here. This means that there is a hundreds of miles wide barrier of continuos slowly southwards drifting multi-year pack ice present here near all year around. The ice barrier stretches along all of Greenlands east coast except for 2-3 months in late summer and autumn when only the southeastern part is ice free.
    The barrier have for all times before 1800 century prevented any ship to reach the coast of North East Greenland.

    Per Michelsen
    http://www.arcticimages.com/Tunu,-_the_backside_of_greenland.htm

    Data from the ages of sail and steam

    There is a wealth of accurate data to be had from ships logs, from which we can reconstruct past climates and ice extents.  Efforts are under way to extract the data from the many thousands of records left by the Royal Navy and the East India Company.  No doubt other nations will provide climate scientists with access to old log books when the great value of this source of climate data becomes more widely known.

    As more and more of this valuable data is incorporated into the climate record, I hope to hear less and less of the 'no data before satellites' nonsense.  Please note: a hope is not necessarily a legitimate expectation!

    As my regular readers will already know: I constantly research old records to find out as much as possible about historic Arctic sea ice seasonal extent.  From those researches it is obvious to me that the Arctic has long since entered a period of rapid decline in sea ice extent and rising temperatures. 

    The seasonal ice extent this year - 2011 - continues to track well below any level recorded throughout written human history.

    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Note to
    Christopher Monckton: the work of fiction - 1421: The Year China Discovered the World, by Gavin Menzies - is not a part of the scientific record!

    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Further reading:

    Volunteers are needed to help with digitizing the handwritten logs currently available: please visit http://www.oldweather.org/

    timesonline.co.uk/.../Captains’ logs yield climate clues
    nytimes.com/.../historic-sea-voyages-buoy-climate-science

    Comments

    Hi Patrick,

    The shape of the developing problem can be equally well appreciated by examining SST anomalies in the North Atlantic/Arctic on a decadal timescale. The nasa/giss site has this facility.

    Shortly, as the ice atop the glass of 7up disappears, the 7up will start to heat faster, and will "go flat" very quickly. The fizz in the Arctic will not be caused by CO2, but methane.

    Try a google of "arctic clathrates"..

    At the risk of crying wolf, BAD WOLF. PETM event possibly imminent...

    PS. IF this is gibberish, please feel free to ignore/delete it.

    logicman
    IF this is gibberish, please feel free to ignore/delete it.

    It isn't, and I won't.  :)  Thanks for your contribution, idunno - good to 'see' you again!
    Hi Patrick, glad to see an update. The only reason I visit Science 2.0. Yes, the NSIDC report should be interesting...

    oh bugger

    my cunning plan for surviving an increasingly anoxic atmosphere has only got as far as sticking two pencils up the nostrils, placing underpants on head and saying "wibble"

    i don't suppose you have any better suggestions?

    seriously, great to see you back in such fine form, even though I think you could have given more space in a previous post to his performance during extra time against benfica in 68;)

    Lord Viscount Wormtongue is entirely beneath your contempt.

    wibble

    logicman
    my cunning plan for surviving an increasingly anoxic atmosphere has only got as far as sticking two pencils up the nostrils, placing underpants on head and saying "wibble"

    "Wibble is as wibble does."
    Edmund Blackadder
    NSDIC report is out; equal record low with 2005.

    logicman
    Many thanks for the tip, Tony
    The report is unusually early, so I likely would have missed seeing it for a day or two.  I'm currently working on my March 2011 ice report, so I'll incorporate the latest data.  Thanks again.