Banner
    Downside To Organic Farming: 90% Losses From Pests Modern Science Defeats Easily
    By News Staff | September 28th 2012 04:03 PM | 3 comments | Print | E-mail | Track Comments
    While organic farmers like to claim the boom in agriculture of the last 30 years was not related to science, history says otherwise. 

    A pest that pre-science farming could never conquer has returned to torment the modern organic kind.  While conventional pesticides, which were created to defeat pests and blight a laissez faire approach to growing could not, kill Orchestes pallicornis, the apple flea weevil, just fine, things are not looking good for organic apple orchards in Michigan, where outbreak population levels have been observed since 2008, and damage has resulted in up to 90% losses for those apple growers. A hundred years ago it was only a sporadic pest but science has been taming agriculture since 1835 so its impact was limited.  Left unchecked, it could become a major issue.

    The apple flea weevil is a small, 2-3 millimeter black weevil with enlarged high legs for jumping. Adults feed on buds and leaves, and the larvae are leaf miners. There are currently no proven management options for use in organic production and as broad-spectrum materials are replaced by reduced-risk compounds, it is possible that the apple flea weevil will increasingly become an important pest in apple production. 


    Adult Orchestes pallicornis (apple flea weevil). Credit: © 2012 Entomological Society of America

    In a new article, the authors discuss the apple flea weevil's biology and the damage it does to plants, as well as methods for growers to monitor and manage them.

    Citation: Nielsen, Anne L.; Pote, John; Buehrer, Krista; Grieshop, Matthew J., 'The Reemergence of an Old Pest, Orchestes pallicornis (Coleoptera: Curculionidae)', Journal of Integrated Pest Management, Volume 3, Number 3, 2012 , pp. D1-D4(4) DOI:10.1603/IPM1200 (Open Access)

    Comments

    Ashwani Kumar
    Some how the lost track of using minimum pesticides or using pesticides with minimum side effects has given way to " organic farming' a term which no one explains what it means to a common man. On Jaipur air port there is label " Organic food" What does it mean. All food we eat is organic. Human beings cant eat inorganic food. 
    May be one day the man will be left to die "  organic death"  a death without treatment or treatment with boiled leaves alone  as all medicines may have some side effects on human body ? 
    So are the poor plants left to die an " organic death" 
    Thor Russell
    well if faced with extinction I expect of course that organic apple farmers will change their rules to make whatever chemical is needed now allowed in "exceptional circumstances"
    Thor Russell
    Hank
    Yes, the rules of 'organic' certification allow for a synthetic chemical when no 'natural' chemical is available. The problem was farmers who held on to the notion that actual organic farming is possible without huge losses.
    Want more no-nonsense, independent science? Buy Science Left Behind