You might think that with Iraq collapsing and Russia and China preparing for giant land grabs, our foreign policy would consist of more than 'global warming stinks' and 'you other countries should have nicer LGBT policies'. If so, there is good news, the State Department is now also criticizing mislabeled international seafood.
Secretary of State John Kerry is directing federal agencies to work together to develop a program to combat seafood fraud. Since there isn't even a program yet, just a directive to create a program, it will be 10 years before various agencies 'work together' to hilarious effect, like when the federal Endangered Species Act tried to restore the Paiute cutthroat trout but was blocked by by the Wilderness Act because the location is so remote it requires a gas-powered generator for the auger - which can't be used in wilderness areas.
Seafood fraud is an issue - last year the advocacy group Oceana found that 39 percent of seafood in stores was mislabeled. That's bad because if people are paying for grouper and getting Asian catfish, they are being bilked, the same way homeopathy and organic food people are being duped by hucksters. It's wrong and tasking individual store owners with the job of figuring it out is unreasonable. It's not a bad thing for Secretary Kerry to be involved in, it sure beats letting him talk to Israel or any other foreign nation.
There has also been a precedent showing that these things can work without causing prices to skyrocket. A century ago a Republican created the Lacey Act, Reagan increased it and then George W. Bush really strengthened it - it killed illegal logging when it came to American consumers. Sure, there is no way to control what the Chinese buy for themselves but in America there has to be a documented supply chain for wood. No one is complaining that furniture is too expensive due to it.
Fraud is bad, because people are paying for a product. If they can't tell the difference, well, that is another issue. I pay more for Coke from Mexico so if it turned out to not be cane sugar, I would be annoyed. It probably isn't happening, Mexico has low levels of seafood fraud also, as you can see in the map below.
Dustin Cranor at Oceana informed me that Oceana can show the extent of seafood fraud using data from 100 studies in 29 countries and the Google Maps Engine. Seafood fraud claims in their studies vary from 1.5 to 100 percent so take that with a grain of salt but we know it is happening if all of those stores in New York City were selling the wrong food.
Credit: Oceana Seafood Fraud Map
- PHYSICAL SCIENCES
- EARTH SCIENCES
- LIFE SCIENCES
- SOCIAL SCIENCES
Subscribe to the newsletter
Stay in touch with the scientific world!
Know Science And Want To Write?
- Parkinson’s Disease Reverted In Rats
- Cycling for Science #1 - Tensegrity
- Artificial Intelligence Lets Machines Weld The Emotional With The Physical
- Weighing Trees - Now With Lasers
- Telomeres And The Genetic Impact On Aging
- Why I’ll Talk Policy With Climate Change Deniers But Not Science
- Alcohol Abuse during the Holidays
- "This is just one reason I went into chemistry. Philosophy just went flying right over my head...."
- "I've tried a very similar pedelec. The one I had was very heavy and had such a high rolling..."
- "I'm a toaster, It's my raison d'être, I toast, therefore I am.Red Dwarf..."
- "Well the bicycle I rode to school and back on for 5 years had very small very thick wheels and..."
- "Great article but just one thing. Maybe it should be.... Only One Third Of Dr. Oz Show..."
- First successful vaccination against 'mad cow'-like wasting disease in deer
- 6 percent of the people reading this article are addicted to the Internet
- Delivering drugs on demand
- Ostwald ripening: Champagne bubble physics may help address future energy needs
- antibodies from llamas might help in the fight against HIV/AIDS