Why do clowns freak us out? And why are robots cute until they look too much like people, and then then they creep us out?
It's our old friend the Uncanny Valley and it basically postulates that the more realistic something gets to a human likeness, the more repulsive it is. I don't mean like realistic special effects as in "Wrath Of The Titans" - that giant, flaming lava hand of Chronos looks cool - but rather likeness when it comes to humanoids, be they zombies or robots.
The Uncanny Valley has long been known, but but finding that line has been experimental. Technologists basically make things more and more realistic until people are creeped out and they compile statistics. It is moderately interesting applied psychology for consumer research but not science. However, now neuroscientists are on the trail, writes Elizabeth Landau on CNN.
First, he is a graphical primer on the uncanny valley:
The uncanny valley. Notice that if the object moves, the affinity or revulsion caused by the machine becomes much more pronounced. Photo Credit: AndroidScience.
Landau writes about Ayse Saygin, professor at the University of California, San Diego, who found something interesting in the neuroscience of creepiness: "The network that normally processes your body movements is more active when you view an android," compared with a stripped-down robot or a human, which could be because the brain has to combine conflicting information.
It's uncanny. And still creepy! Professor Hiroshi Ishiguro. Link: The Guardian
Is it because we know eerily realistic robots and most clowns look alive but we know they are not, and thus they play on our fear of death (or Jamaicans, in the case of voodoo zombies)? That's empathy, not science, but still worth considering.
Chris Rollins wrote about the uncanny valley being scaled by, you guess it, Japanese researchers. Here is a video. Still too weird? Or are people getting more and more accustomed as time, and realistic special effects, march on?
H/T Mark Changizi
- PHYSICAL SCIENCES
- EARTH SCIENCES
- LIFE SCIENCES
- SOCIAL SCIENCES
Subscribe to the newsletter
Stay in touch with the scientific world!
Know Science And Want To Write?
- Suggestion: The EM Drive Is Getting The Appropriate Level Of Attention From The Science Community
- It's Naive To Pretend Differences Between Women And Men Are Just Genetics
- Bang! Meet The Highest-Energy Hadron Collision Ever Imaged!
- Will Aspartame Critics Now Be Less Bitter?
- GMOs Have Formaldehyde? Bizarre Claim Challenged By Experts
- New Results From The LHC At 13 TeV!
- Bees: Activists Remain Silent While This Pollinator Killer Decimates Millions
- "Just one question: those two jets...And the issue of rare statistics...Perhaps you could post some..."
- "Thanks, glad my article helped...."
- "Oh, silly me, I meant to write divided by the wavelength. Sometimes I come out with the wrong words..."
- "Yes, well caught, I got it upside down when I corrected it last night, fixed now :)...."
- "Excellent article. Thank you for the objective analysis that so few journalists treat this subject..."
- Environmental activists are ignoring the real bee killer
- Corporate leader’s science creds under attack
- Rare bacteria cause outbreak in NYC
- John Stossel rips the EPA and NRDC too. Because they’re practically the same thing
- Fact checking pHony water
- Hopewell NJ votes gas pipeline off the island; why not shut down your entire energy supply to save Mother Earth?
- How bees naturally vaccinate their babies
- Mild hypothermia in deceased organ donors improves organ function in kidney transplant
- Trying to quit smoking? First strengthen self-control
- Paralyzed men move legs thanks to non-invasive spinal cord stimulation
- California 'rain debt' equal to average full year of precipitation