Banner
    Ohm For Christmas
    By Patrick Lockerby | December 23rd 2011 01:25 PM | 17 comments | Print | E-mail | Track Comments
    About Patrick

    Retired engineer, 60+ years young. Computer builder and programmer. Linguist specialising in language acquisition and computational linguistics....

    View Patrick's Profile
    Ohm For Christmas

    The ohm is the unit of electrical resistance.  It is named in honor of the genius of Georg Ohm, who figured out that the flow of electricity in materials from a 'hot' source might just resemble the flow of heat from a hot source.  Ever since we started measuring electrical resistance in ohms, electricians and engineers have been making up atrocious puns based on that term.  I decided not to make an exception here.

    Christmas is a time to be thinking about the wider implications of the laws of thermodynamics and the fact that the universe is made of stuff, that the stuff is made of atoms, and that atoms are made of at least one electron and a few other bits.  You can forget the other bits, mostly.  That's about it really: you can understand most of electronic and electrical engineering just by knowing a thing or two about why electrons tend to bite you if you crowd them into too tight a space.  What has this to do with Christmas?  Batteries!  It seems to me that these days if you give any average kid any average toy it will need batteries.  If you never learn anything else about electricity and electronics, a sound knowledge of the life and death of a battery will save you money.  Your application of the laws of physics to the laws of bank balances will help you to learn something of economics.  The fact that all of this will help address the problems of global warming and annoy the likes of Lord Monckton is an added bonus.


    An all too brief history of the battery


    The Baghdad battery may or may not have been a real battery.  Like all obsolete batteries, it is of historic value only and likely will not fit inside your new radio-controlled helicopter.  The first demonstrated and replicable chemical battery was Volta's pile, which he built in 1800.  It is based on the use of two different metals, so it used to be easily replicated with copper and silver coins.  Many modern 'copper' and 'silver' coins are pretty useless for making a voltaic pile.  Some are just scrap iron.   They are money by fiat, but nobody ever made electricity flow by fiat.  (The electric chair doesn't count.)


    The attraction of shiny new pennies

    Since Volta's day, many different methods have been invented to provide consumers with electricity in various pretty packages.  And consumers have striven to keep pace with science and technology by finding new ways to kill those pretty batteries.


    Batteries - some old, some new, and some killed - but not by me!

    When I was a small child, growing up in Kent, England, a few householders were still using Leclanché cells to power their doorbells.  At that time you could buy a big square cardboard-wrapped doorbell battery with brass nuts on top.  Either battery would leak alkali and corrode the terminals.


    Leclanché cell

    Mains electricity on a national grid was a fairly new thing back then, and many people living out in the sticks had no mains.  Their radios - which they called 'wireless sets' -  were powered by a wet battery - known as an accumulator - and a big square cardboard-wrapped battery capable of giving unwary users a nasty shock.  It was essential to have two batteries: one powered the heaters (filaments) in the vacuum tubes and the other provided the high voltage - known then as 'high tension' -  which made the valve / vacuum-tube thingies work and which made the service engineer look incredibly brave as he worked on a live circuit. 


    A valve / vacuum-tube thingy

    In those days, replacing the so-called 'dry' battery and recharging the wet battery were 'black arts' known only to the people in the radio shop that wireless owners gave money to.  It was probably best to leave accumulator charging to the shop.  Back then we had D.C. mains, which meant that you could string a heap of batteries across the mains and watch them until you could see bubbles through the glass case.  Fragile glass + hydrogen gas + bare mains electricity cables = foobar!  Today, we have plenty of standard sizes of rechargeable batteries that anyone can recharge safely, so there is really no need for any average user to buy disposable batteries.  However, if you treat rechargeable batteries casually then they will die sooner rather than later.

    I learned about radio and electronics by reading a lot and by taking old vacuum-tube radios to bits and then taking the bits to bits.  I still take things to bits, but only in order to repair them or to salvage re-usable components.  I also enjoy old books.  One great thing about books is that you don't have to take them to bits to see how they work.  Another great thing about books is that you get a sharper image than with bits of junk when you lay them on a flat bed scanner.  Batteries are a lot different from books and electrical equipment: they make a huge mess when you take them to bits.  You should not take a battery to bits unless you really know what you are doing, and probably not even then.   Most especially you should not take a diesel locomotive battery to bits by shorting the terminals just after charging it - not even in the lecture hall, regardless of audience satisfaction.



    It's a good thing that telecommunications devices have now improved to the point where you can dial at least 10 wrong numbers before the battery goes flat, but one of my major beefs is that there are so many different charger plugs, polarities and voltages.  Why?  You can stick a regulator on a pinhead now, so we could all use one standard type of charger regardless of battery voltage.  No more wall-wart landfill mountains.  Maybe, one day.  In the meantime, I am in process of designing an intelligent battery management system for Nimh batteries.  I also have other electronics projects in the pipeline, such as a solar panel orientation controller, a hot wire ammeter1, an analog computer2 and other such fun applied physics stuff3.

    This article is intended to whet your appetite if you aren't already interested in electronics.  As I build various gadgets I intend to write more articles about how they were designed and built, and the science behind them.  Before anyone can understand how to make batteries last longer they need to understand how sources want to push electricity out and how loads want to draw it in.  All sources in the known universe - and that includes batteries - have a limit to how fast they can pump out electrons.  All loads have a limit to how fast they can draw electrons in.  The best circuit designs match the source to the load.  This is called impedance matching.  In the real world, impedance mismatch means that if you plug a 12 volt gadget into the 110 or 220 volt mains it will do things that its designer never intended.  Over the course of the next few articles I will try to explain why.

    Oh yes: batteries.  Batteries have internal resistance.  That fact is very important.  Dead batteries don't have zero electricity in them: they have higher resistance / impedance than usable batteries.  Any electricity which they can supply is too feeble to do anything useful.  All things which supply or conduct electricity have the property of resistance to the flow of current.  I shall try to explain this in my next article on electronics.
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Footnotes


    [1] - A heated wire expands in length.  It also softens.  A hot wire ammeter is a device which mechanically amplifies the tiny movements involved and indicates the electrical current on a scale.

    [2] - A 'black box' which can be used to make interesting sounds and laser light shows and which can even do boring stuff such as maths if you like that sort of thing.

    [3] - such as the Wimshurst machine, perhaps.

    Comments

    The Mythbusters built some baghdad batteries and declared them *plausible* for use in electroplating, acupuncture and possible spiritual uses. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MythBusters_(2005_season)#Baghdad_Battery

    Can't wait to read more!

    Fubar, please
    Fowled up beyond all recognition. Somewhat worse than a Snafu; situation normal all fowled up.
    There are those who would say that the Fs do not stand for fowled, coming from the military they might be right.

    Good to see you back

    Fred Phillips
    That would be fouled. (Sorry, I'm an editor, I can't help it.) Unless a chicken shorted the circuit...
    Funny how we can see other peoples tiny mistakes and still miss our own whoppers. Fouled of course.

    logicman
    Oops!  Looks like I fubarred!  :-)
    rholley
    Robert H. Olley Quondam Physics Department University of Reading England
    rholley
    Martin Ohm, the brother of Georg Simon, was a significant mathematician.  His MacTutor biography states:
    In 1815 he published Die reine Elementar-Mathematik which is famed for containing the name "golden section" for the first time (at least this is the first known occurrence of the term).
    though my own readings, as I remember, dug up the fact that the term (Goldener Schnitt) only appeared in a later edition.  Before that, around 1600, it was given the name Divina Proportione by Pacioli.  The Classical Greeks called it the Extreme and Mean Ratio.

    Robert H. Olley Quondam Physics Department University of Reading England
    logicman
    Thanks for your contribution, Robert.  I hadn't known before about Martin Ohm.  As for the van man, I refuse to be out-punned: as you will see in my follow-up article about Georg Ohm.
    The charging/wallwart problem has gotten better in the last year or two with many devices such as phones, Kindles, and cameras using mini-USB or Micro-USB connectors for their charger. I especially liked the image I got of the locomotive battery experiment. I assume it wasn't from a new GE Hybrid which would have been very bad, but having accidently arc welded a screwdriver with a car battery I get the picture.

    I look forward to more amusing battery articles.

    logicman
    Using a computer's USB port as a charging device is not a good idea.  Firstly, older computer PSUs aren't designed to give the required power, so using the USB port of an older computer as a power source may cause the computer to crash.  Secondly, it makes no sense to power up an entire computer just to charge a battery.  What a waste of power that is!  Having a car 12V to USB adapter, or a wall-wart USB outlet is fine, I suppose, but the best solution using currently available technology, imho, is to use a solar panel to charge a 12 volt battery and then use that as a 24-hours available source for charging smaller batteries.  In fact, I am currently designing such a battery-charging system for my own use.

    As for more amusing battery articles, did you want more-amusing or more-battery articles?  Either way, I aim to please.  :-)
    rholley
    I aim to please.  :-)
    Speaking of myself:

    We aim to please.
    Occasionally we hit the target.
    Robert H. Olley Quondam Physics Department University of Reading England
    Oh, a Wimshurst machine! We had one at school (must have been the end of the '70). Schocking apparatus ....

    logicman
    Let's get something straight: I do the funnies around here!  ;-)
    Hank
    Does that reasoning ever work?  Over the Christmas holiday my wife hosted a "Real Housewives of the North Pole" party at the house (don't ask, it is too complicated) and after they were all liquored up they wanted a picture of the group.

    I dutifully get my camera and am trying to take the picture and I hear various comments; 'you look nice' and 'take off your shirt' and more so I put down the camera and said, "Excuse me, I am the only one who does the objectifying in this house."

    There was a silent pause for a few seconds and then one of them said, "Go make us a sammich, bitch."
    Want more no-nonsense, independent science? Buy Science Left Behind
    MikeCrow
    I'm thinking you might have missed a great opportunity to say "you first" :)

    And get it on camera!
    Never is a long time.
    logicman
    Let's get something straight: I do the funnies around here!  ;-)

    Another beautiful theory spoiled by hilarious facts!